Maryland case law › Medley v. Warden

Medley v. Warden

219 Md. 688 (1959) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: RemandedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Maryland Court of Appeals addressed whether counsel must be appointed for an indigent petitioner seeking post-conviction relief under the Post Conviction Procedure Act, Code (1958 Supp.), Art. 27, secs. 645A et seq., when the petitioner did not expressly request counsel but filed an uncontroverted pauper's affidavit stating he had no funds 'wherewith to provide for any or any part of legal assistance for his defence.' The lower court had not appointed counsel. The Court held that this affidavit fell short of showing that the petitioner 'voluntarily and intelligently' waived the right to counsel, as suggested in Byrd v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary, 219 Md. 681, 147 A.2d 701. The Court further held that, in the absence of an express waiver, counsel must be appointed in every case where the petitioner is without funds, for the reasons stated in Hobbs
Questions presented
  • Whether the petitioner's uncontroverted pauper affidavit, which did not expressly request counsel, constituted a voluntary and intelligent waiver of the right to counsel.
  • Whether counsel must be appointed in every case where the petitioner is without funds, absent an express waiver.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In this application for leave to appeal under the Post Conviction Procedure Act, Code (1958 Supp.), Art. 27, secs. 645A et seq., it appears that counsel was not appointed in the lower court. The petitioner did not, in express terms, request the appointment of counsel, but his affidavit that he was a pauper, which was not controverted, also asserted that he had no funds “wherewith to provide for any or any part of legal assistance for his defence”. We think this falls short of a showing that the petitioner “voluntarily and intelligently” waived the right to counsel, as suggested in Byrd v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary, 219 Md. 681 , 147 A. 2d 701 .

In the absence of express waiver, counsel must be appointed in every case where the petitioner is without funds, for the reasons stated in Hobbs v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary, 219 Md. 684, 686 , 148 A. 2d 380, 382 . Application for leave to appeal granted, and case remanded for further proceedings.