Maryland case law › Mitchell v. Mitchell

Mitchell v. Mitchell

10 Md. 234 (1856) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedMason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on exceptions taken by the plaintiff during trial. The plaintiff sought to prove the annual profits of the land in dispute by offering testimony from Mr. Jenkins, a neighboring farmer, regarding the net profits of his own adjoining farm. The circuit court rejected this testimony, and the plaintiff excepted. A majority of the Court of Appeals held that the testimony was properly refused, reasoning that the profits one farmer realizes are not a reliable measure of what another farmer might make, even if the quantity and quality of their land are equal, because farmers differ in industry and skill. On the question of limitations, the court was equally divided, so the judgment of the court below was affirmed on that exception. The plaintiff also excepted to the rejection of a prayer that sought to charge taxes and other expenses against profits from
Questions presented
  • Whether the circuit court erred in rejecting testimony from a neighboring farmer as to the net profits of his own farm, offered to show the annual profits of the land in dispute.
  • Whether the statute of limitations bars recovery for certain years, the court being equally divided.
  • Whether the circuit court erred in rejecting a prayer to charge taxes and other expenses upon the profits of years excluded by limitations from the recovery.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Mason, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The plaintiff, to show the annual profits of the land, offered to prove by Mr. Jenkins, who lived upon the adjoining farm, the amount of net profits which his farm yielded. This testimony was objected to, and rejected by the court, and this forms the first exception. This testimony, a majority of the court are of opinion, was properly refused for the reason assigned, upon an analogous point, by this court, in the case of Keedy vs. Newcomer, 1 Md. Rep., 251 , namely, “that it is no very unusual thing, that thriving and industrious farmers find themselves neighbors to those who are not so distinguished for those qualities,” and hence wdiat one man might make upon his farm, would be no criterion as to what his neighbor has made, even conceding the quantity and quality of the land of each to be equal, which is by no means universally true.

Upon the question of limitations the courtis equally divided, and therefore the judgment of the court below must be affirmed upon the second exception. The proposition submitted by the plaintiff’s counsel in the third exception, namely, to make the taxes, &c., a charge upon the profits of the years excluded by limitations from the recovery, was doubtless intended to be a recognition of the principle asserted in the case of Ewalt vs. Gray, 6 Watts, 427 . We think, under the decisions of this court, the circuit court 242 could not have done otherwise than reject the prayer; for conceding the principle announced in it to be correct, yet it was defective in assuming the existence of profits during the years barred by limitations. The finding of the fact, whether or not there were profits, should have been left to the jury.

Upon this point see the cases of Crawford vs. Berry, 6 G. & J., 63; Balt. & Susq. R. R. Co. vs. Woodruff, 4 Md. Rep., 242 ; Boyd vs. McCann, Ante, 118; and other cases. Judgment affirmed.