Maryland case law › Murphy v. Patapsco Insurance

Murphy v. Patapsco Insurance

6 Md. 99 (1854) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a case stated, in which the parties agreed that if the appellee (Patapsco Insurance Company) was entitled to recover, judgment should be entered for a sum specified. The appellant, Murphy, was a delinquent stockholder whose stock had been forfeited under the 2nd section of the Act of 1813, ch. 55. The company sought to hold him liable for his proportion of losses arising from risks taken before his refusal to comply with his obligation. The auditor's account showed that a loss had occurred, and the case stated fixed the amount of the judgment. Murphy argued that the company had a duty to offer the forfeited stock for sale and then adjust the account between the company and him. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, rejected that interpretation of the charter. The Court held that the express language of the statute made
Questions presented
  • Is the appellee entitled to recover?
  • Whether the charter imposed a duty on the company to offer the forfeited stock for sale and then adjust the account between the company and the appellant.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. This case comes before us on a case stated. It is agreed that if the court should be of the opinion that the appellee is entitled to recover, that the judgment shall be entered up for a sum specified. This deprives us of the power to assess any other damages.

The question then is: — Is the appellee entitled to recover ? We think it is, and we found this opinion on the express language of the 2nd sec. of the act of 1813, cb. 55, which after providing for the forfeiture of the' stock of a delinquent stockholder, goes on to declare,, that notwithstanding such forfeiture, he shall, “neverthelessr remaint liable for the proportion of any loss which may arise from risks taken antecedent to said refusal,” on his part, to-comply with his obligation-. It is clear from the account of the auditor that a loss had occurred, and the case stated- fixes the' amount of the judgment. It was argued by the counsel, that there was-a duty imposed on the company to offer the stock for sale, and then to 104 adjust the account between the company and the appellant.

We do not think the charter can be so interpreted. It provides that the stock when forfeited shall be transferred to any person applying for it; but it does not appear that any application was made for this stock of the appellant, and being utterly worthless, we suppose any effort to dispose of it would have proved unproductive of any benefit to the appellant.- We affirm the judgment.- Judgment affirmed.