Maryland case law › Murray v. Director, Patuxent Institution

Murray v. Director, Patuxent Institution

8 Md. App. 400 (1970) · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of MarylandDisposition: RemandedThompson, J.✓ Good law
SummaryJames L. Murray filed his first petition for post-conviction relief in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, alleging that his retained trial counsel failed to perfect a direct appeal despite Murray's timely request within thirty days of sentencing. The hearing judge found as a fact that Murray had indeed requested his retained counsel to file an appeal within thirty days of sentencing, but denied relief based on older case law that did not extend the duties of court-appointed counsel to retained counsel. On application for leave to appeal, the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland considered whether the duties imposed on court-appointed counsel by Maryland Rule 719 b 6 (effective September 1, 1967) — specifically the duty to advise the accused of the right to appeal and to assist in preparing and filing an order of appeal when directed by the accused — also apply to retained counsel. The Cour
Questions presented
  • Whether the duties imposed on court-appointed counsel by Maryland Rule 719 b 6 also apply to retained counsel, such that a belated appeal must be granted when retained counsel fails to comply with the rule.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Thompson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. James L. Murray applies for leave to appeal from an order filed in the Criminal Court of Baltimore denying relief sought by applicant’s first petition under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act. The hearing judge found that within thirty days from the imposition of sentence the applicant requested his retained counsel to 401 file an appeal, but, relying on older cases, the hearing judge denied relief. Maryland Rule 719 b 6 (effective September 1, 1967) establishes duties for court appointed counsel as follows: “. . .counsel shall advise the accused concerning his right to appeal and his right to apply for a review of his sentence.

If directed by the accused, counsel shall assist in the preparation of an application for review of sentence under Rule 762 (Review of Sentence) and an order for appeal, and shall file same over the signature of the accused.” In Evans v. Warden, 8 Md. App. 26 , 257 A. 2d 474 we held the same standards must be met by retained counsel, and upon counsel’s failure to comply with the rule, in cases arising after its effective date, a belated appeal must be granted. Application for leave to appeal granted; case remoMded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.