Maryland case law › Nash v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Nash v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

243 Md. 700 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner pleaded guilty in the Circuit Court for Garrett County on July 27, 1964, to two counts of sodomy and was sentenced to ten years (later reduced to seven) in the Maryland House of Correction. On June 14, 1965, he filed a petition for relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act; a hearing was held before Judge Getty on November 22, 1965, and relief was denied. He applied for leave to appeal. The Court of Appeals denied the application for the reasons stated in Judge Getty's opinion, except for Judge Getty's statement of law regarding the unavailability of post conviction relief when a claim is based on incompetent representation by trial counsel or on alleged prejudice of the trial judge. The Court clarified that relief can be granted on those grounds, but the facts here did not merit it. On the ineffective assistance claim, the Court reaffirmed that inadequacy of coun
Questions presented
  • Whether post conviction relief is available when a claim is based on incompetent representation by trial counsel and when based on the alleged prejudice of the trial judge.
  • Whether the contention of inadequacy of counsel is restricted in post conviction procedure to allegations of fraud or collusion.
  • Whether a complaint grounded on advice to plead guilty, standing alone, alleges such deficiency of counsel as to warrant relief.
  • Whether the claim that statements made at the trial by the state's attorney prejudiced the judge is reviewable under the Act where the petitioner pleaded guilty and the sentence imposed was within the statutory limit.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Pbr Curiam. Petitioner, after pleading guilty, was convicted in the Circuit Court for Garrett County on July 27, 1964, on two counts of sodomy and was sentenced to ten years (later reduced to seven) in the Maryland House of Correction. On June 14, 1965, a petition for relief was filed under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, a hearing was held before Judge Getty on November 22, 1965, and relief was denied. An application for leave to appeal was filed and is hereby denied for the reasons stated in Judge Getty’s opinion with the exception of the statement of law as to the unavailability of post conviction relief when a claim is based on incompetent representation by trial counsel and when based on the alleged prejudice of the trial judge.

While relief can be given on these grounds, the facts in this case do not merit it. As was stated in Hyde v. Warden, 235 Md. 641, 646 , the contention of inadequacy of counsel is not restricted in our post conviction procedure to allegations of fraud or collusion and relief is available if the representation is so deficient as to go to the very fairness of the trial, Pressley v. Warden, 242 Md. 405 . Such deficiency as to warrant relief is not alleged, however, when, as here, the complaint is grounded on the advice to plead guilty which, standing alone, amounts to an exercise of tactical judgment. Furthermore, Judge Getty’s express finding that petitioner was adequately represented by experienced counsel who was part of the case from the time of the preliminary hearing supported as it is by the record disposes of the matter. 702 The claim that statements made at the trial by the state’s attorney prejudiced the judge is without merit because the petitioner pleaded guilty and the sentence imposed was within the statutory limit and therefore is not a matter of review under the Act.

Davis v. Warden, 235 Md. 637 . Application denied.