Maryland case law › Northern Central Railway Co. v. State

Northern Central Railway Co. v. State

93 Md. 737 (1901) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a retrial following this Court's earlier decision in State v. Northern Central Railway Co., 90 Md. 447. At the first trial, the lower court had granted the railway company's first prayer and rejected its second; this Court reversed and awarded a new trial. At the retrial, the defendant (the Railway Company) again offered its first and second prayers, which were the same prayers offered at the first trial. The trial court rejected both prayers and entered judgment for the plaintiff (the State). The defendant excepted to the refusal to grant its two prayers and appealed. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, held that the questions involved on this appeal were the same as those decided in the prior reported case. Without repeating the reasons given in that earlier opinion, the Court concluded there was no error in rejecting both prayers offered by the defend
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in rejecting both prayers offered by the defendant (the Railway Company) at the retrial.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court in a per curiam opinion filed on December 7th, 1900, said : The questions involved on this appeal are the same that were decided- by this Court in the case of The State of Maryland v. The Northern Central Railway Company, reported in 90 Md. 447 . At that time we were called upon, at the instance of the State, to review the rulings of the Court below,, which had granted the first prayer offered by the defendant (the Railway Company), and rejected the second. We reversed the lower Court and awarded a new trial. At the retrial of the case, the first and second prayers offered by the. defendant (being the same offered at the first trial) were rejected and judgment was entered for the plaintiff.

The defendant excepted to the action of the Court in refusing to grant its-two prayers and prosecuted this appeal. Without repeating-them, for the reasons given in the opinion reported as above-stated, we think there was no error in rejecting both prayers offered by the defendant (now appellant), and will affirm the-judgment.