Maryland case law › Nusz v. Grove

Nusz v. Grove

27 Md. 391 (1867) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBartol, J.✓ Good law
SummaryElias Grove died intestate without children, survived by his widow (the appellee) and by the children of his deceased sister (the appellants), who claimed as next of kin. The Orphans' Court of Frederick County granted letters of administration to the widow, and the next of kin appealed. The Court of Appeals (Bartol, J.) affirmed. The Court held that under Code, Art. 93, sec. 19, 'if there be a widow and no child, the widow shall be preferred,' and that the widow was therefore entitled to letters of administration unless the proof took the case out of the statute. The appellants argued that a post-nuptial arrangement, evidenced by a bond of John Stone and George Feaga dated November 7, 1835, and testified to by Peter Fulrat, precluded the widow from participating in the estate and thus from administering it, relying on Ward v. Thompson, Maurer v. Naill, and Edelen v. Edelen. The Court rej
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellee, as widow, is entitled to letters of administration on the estate of her deceased husband under Code, Art. 93, sec. 19, where there is a widow and no child.
  • Whether the post-nuptial arrangement evidenced by the bond of John Stone and George Feaga of November 7, 1835, and testified to by Peter Fulrat, precludes the appellee from all right to participate in the estate of her deceased husband and consequently from administration.
  • Whether the separation of the appellee from her husband deprives her of her share in his personal estate or her right to administer.
  • Whether the appellee's inability to read or write is a legal disqualification to administer.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Babtol, J., delivered the opinion of this Court. This is. an appeal from an order of the Orphans’ Court of Frederick County, granting letters of administration on the estate of Elias Grove, deceased, to the appellee, his widow. The deceased died without-children; the appellants are the children of his deceased sister,- and claim as next of kin. By the Code, Art. 93, sec. 19, it is provided, “ if there be a widow and no child, the widow shall be preferred.” This case comes within this provision, and the appellee is entitled to letters of administration ; unless there be something in the proof to take the case out of -the operation of this provision of the Code.

Cook vs. Carr, 19 Md. Rep., 1 . The appellee and Elias Grove were married in February, 1835 ; a few months afterwards she separated from him, and continued always thereafter to live in a state of separation. The causes which led to the separation are not disclosed in the record ; but it appears both from the petition and answer to have been by mutual consent. The separation alone does not deprive the wife of her share in her husband’s personal estate, or her right to administer.

The marriage not having been dissolved, she is his widow still. Slatter vs. Slatter, 1 Younge & Coll., (Ex. R.,) 28 ; Lambell vs. Lambell, 3 Haggard, 568 ; Chappell vs. Chappell, 7 Eccl. Rep. 451.

The appellants contend that the post-nuptial arrangement, evidenced by the bond of John Stone and George Feaga of the 7th November, 1835, and testified to by the witness Peter Fulrat, precludes the appellee from all right to participate in the estate of her deceased husband, and consequently she is not entitled to administration under the decisions in Ward vs. Thompson, 6 G. & J., 401 349 ; Maurer vs. Naill, 5 Md. Rep., 324 , and Edelen vs. Edelen, 11 Md. Rep., 415 . (Decided 12th July, 1867.) Rut at the time that settlement was made, the appellee being a- married woman, had not the capacity to make a valid and binding contract, except as to her separate estate. Burton et al. vs. Marshall, 4 Gill, 488 ; Norris vs. Lantz & Hyde, 18 Md. Rep., 268 ; see also Slatter vs. Slatter, above cited. Under these decisions, the contract of the appellee must he held to he null and void, and it cannot he enforced against her, or operate to deprive her of her share in her husband’s estate.

It is no legal disqualification of the appellee to administer, that she is unable to read or write. The right of administration is conferred on her by the Code, and the Orphans’ Court is not vested with the discretion to deprive her of that right, for such cause. Cook vs. Carr, 19 Md. Rep., 1 . Order affirmed.