Maryland case law › Patterson v. State

Patterson v. State

236 Md. 649 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was charged under two indictments, including counts for breaking a storehouse with intent to steal goods worth $100 or more, and stealing goods worth more than $5. He elected to plead guilty to a count charging him with breaking with intent to steal less than $100, and carrying a concealed weapon. He was sentenced to eighteen months on the one count, and two years on the other, to run consecutively. On appeal, Patterson challenged his sentences as cruel and unusual and his representation by counsel as inadequate. The Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that a sentence within statutory limits is not cruel or unusual, and that it is immaterial that a co-defendant received a shorter sentence. The Court also found no merit to the claim of inadequate representation, noting that the record showed he was fully advised as to the nature of his guilty pleas, and that even if his arres
Questions presented
  • Whether the sentences imposed were cruel and unusual punishment?
  • Whether the appellant's representation by counsel was so inadequate as to make a farce of the trial?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The appellant was charged under two indictments, including counts for breaking a storehouse with intent to steal goods worth $100 or more, and stealing goods worth more than $5. He elected to plead guilty to a count charging him with breaking with intent to steal less than $100, and carrying a concealed weapon. He was sentenced to eighteen months on the one count, and two years on the other, to run consecutively.

The appellant’s complaint as to the sentences is unfounded. He received the maximum in each case, but he had a long criminal record. We have repeatedly held that a sentence within the statutory limits is not cruel or unusual. Gleaton v. State, 235 Md. 271, 277 .

It is immaterial that a co-defendant received a shorter sentence. Reynolds v. Warden, 229 Md. 623, 626 ; Stevens v. State, 232 Md. 33, 42 . The appellant’s complaint as to his representation by counsel is without merit. The record shows that he was fully advised as to the nature of his guilty pleas.

Gleaton v. State, supra. He argues that if his counsel had told him (and he says he did not) that his arrest was illegal, he would not have pleaded guilty. Of course, we do not know what his lawyer told him. But even if we assume, without deciding, that his arrest was without probable cause and hence illegal, and that the stolen goods and the razor found on the appellant could have been kept out of evidence, that would not prove incompetence on the part of his counsel.

There were his own admissions and the admissions of his co-defendant. There was the circumstantial and other evidence of the crimes. If convicted on either the count for breaking with intent to steal goods worth $100 or more, or the count for breaking and stealing goods worth more than $5, he could have been sentenced to ten years. Advice to 651 plead guilty to the lesser offense may have been sound trial tactics.

The maximum sentences could not exceed three and a half years, as he admitted he was informed by his counsel. We cannot find on this record that the representation was so inadequate as to make a farce of the trial. Cf. Stevens v. State, 230 Md. 47, 49 ; Ogle v. Warden, 204 A. 2d 179 , and Evans v. State, 236 Md. 532 .

Judgment affirmed.