Maryland case law › Pennington v. State

Pennington v. State

299 Md. 23 (1984) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherRodowsky✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a dissenting opinion by Judge Rodowsky in Pennington v. State, 299 Md. 23 (1984). The dissent addresses only the propriety of a remand. The majority had remanded the case for a determination of whether there was a violation of Maryland Code, Article 27, § 591 and Maryland Rule 746 requiring the sanction of dismissal. Judge Rodowsky disagrees with the remand because he does not believe dismissal should be the sanction for a violation of § 591 and Rule 746, as explained in his dissenting opinion in Calhoun v. State, 299 Md. 1, 472 A.2d 436 (1984). He reasons that any inquiry into the reasons for delay is an administrative matter, not a matter affecting the guilt or innocence of the accused or any constitutional right. The relevant relationship is between the Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals as administrative head of the Maryland Court system and the administrative and other judg
Questions presented
  • Whether the case should be remanded to determine if there was a violation of § 591 and Rule 746 requiring the sanction of dismissal.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

RODOWSKY, Judge, dissenting: I respectfully dissent. The only reason for a remand is to determine if “there was a violation of § 591 and Rule 746 requiring the sanction of dismissal. . . . ” Because I do not believe dismissal should be the sanction, as explained in my dissenting opinion in Calhoun v. State, 299 Md. 1 , 472 A.2d 436 (1984), there is no purpose in remanding. Any inquiry into the reasons for delay is an administrative matter. The relevant relationship is that between the Chief Judge of this Court, as administrative head of the Maryland Court system, and the administrative and other judges of the court where the delay occurred.

The delay has nothing to do with the guilt or innocence of the accused or with any 32 constitutional right of the accused, so that inquiry into the reason for delay need not be made on the record in the criminal case.