Maryland case law › Pumphrey v. State

Pumphrey v. State

17 Md. 57 (1861) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a submission to the court below on an agreed statement of facts, presenting a single question: whether the appointment of Connell as tax collector on September 13, 1853, was valid. The appellants challenged the appointment, arguing that the Act of 1842, ch. 269, prohibited the commissioners from reappointing a person who had previously failed to qualify as collector. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Tuck, J., rejected that interpretation. The Court held that the Act of 1842 does not, either expressly or by implication, negate the authority of the commissioners to reappoint a person who had failed to qualify under a prior appointment. The Court reasoned that while such neglect or omission might often furnish a good reason not to reappoint, there could be satisfactory cause for the failure in other cases, and a contrary interpretation would deprive the public of
Questions presented
  • the validity of Connell's appointment, on the 13th day of September 1853.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The agreement on which this case was submitted to the court below, contains nothing about the assessment of taxes; nor was such statement necessary to the decision of the only question presented by the record, to wit: the validity of Connell’s appointment, on the 13th day of September 1853. We have no doubt of the correctness of the judgment. The Act of 1842, eh. 269, does not, in terms or by implication, negative the authority of the commissioners to reappoint a person as collector who may have failed to qualify under a previous appointment.

Such neglect or omission might, in many cases, furnish a very good reason why he should not be reappointed; but, in others, there might be satisfactory cause shown for the failure, and the public might be deprived of the services of good officers, if the appellants’ interpreta 62 tion of the law were accepted. The matter is confided to the judgment and discretion of the appointing power, to be exercised according to the circumstances of cases as they may arise. (Decided March 6th, 1861.) Judgment affirmed.