Maryland case law › Rau v. Bennis

Rau v. Bennis

49 Md. 316 (1878) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedRobinson, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a judgment of a lower court. The appellant failed to have the record transmitted to the Court of Appeals within the time prescribed by law. The appellee sought to have the record sent up, relying on the Act of 1864, ch. 322, which permits the lower court to strike out the entry of appeal and proceed to execution if the appellant fails to pay for the record within nine months. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Robinson, J., held that the Act of 1864 does not interfere with the appellee's right to have the record transmitted when the appellant neglects to do so within the time prescribed by law. The remedy provided by the Act is cumulative. Because the record was not transmitted as required, the appeal was dismissed with costs to the appellee. The Court did not address any other issues. The opinion is brief and focuses solely on the procedural question of whethe
Questions presented
  • Whether the Act of 1864, ch. 322, interferes with the right of the appellee to have the record sent up when the appellant neglects to have it done within the time prescribed by law.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Robinson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The Act of 1864, ch. 322, provides, it is true, that if the record is prepared in time by the clerk, and is not transmitted to this Court within nine months after the appeal is taken, by the failure of the appellant to pay for such record, the Court from which the appeal was taken may strike out the entry of appeal and proceed to execute as if no appeal had been taken. But this act in no manner interferes with the right of the appellee to have the record sent up, if the appellant neglects to have it done within the time prescribed by law. The remedy thus provided by the Act of 1864 is cumulative.

The appeal in this case must he dismissed with costs to the appellee. Appeal dismissed.