Maryland case law › Raymond v. Reed

Raymond v. Reed

195 Md. 716 (1950) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DeniedMarkell, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis matter came before the Court of Appeals as an "appeal" from an order of a lower court discharging the petitioner after a hearing on a writ of habeas corpus. The order was entered November 10, 1949, and the "appeal" was filed November 18, 1949, but the papers were not transmitted to the Court of Appeals until March 10, 1950. The Court noted that the papers were meagre and did not include any statement by the judge setting forth the grounds of the application, the questions involved, and the reasons for the court's action, as required by 1947 Supp., Art. 42, sec. 3B. It did not appear that the order was stayed or that the petitioner was admitted to bail. Apparently the maximum terms for which the petitioner had been committed had expired, but even this was not clear. No brief was filed in support of the application for appeal. The Court stated that it may be that a prisoner's right to
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court has power to grant the application for leave to appeal.
  • Whether the application should be granted given the total inaction of the State's Attorney.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Markell, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an “appeal”, which will be treated as an application for leave to appeal, from an order discharging the petitioner after hearing on a writ of habeas corpus. The order was entered November 10, 1949, the “appeal” filed November 18, 1949 with the clerk of the lower court. The papers were not transmitted to this court until March 10, 1950.

Cf. Eule 49. The papers are meagre and do not include any statement by the judge setting forth the grounds of the application, the questions involved, and the reasons of the court for the action taken. 1947 Supp., Art. 42, sec. 3B. It does not appear that the order was stayed or petitioner admitted to bail.

Apparently the maximum terms for which petitioner had been committed had expired, but even this may not be clear. No brief has been filed in support of the applica 717 tion for appeal. It may be that a prisoner’s right to appeal would not be lost by delay of the clerk in transmitting the papers. In the instant case, even if we now have power (which we do not decide) to grant the application we think that in view of the total inaction of the State’s Attorney in the matter, the application should be denied.

Application denied, without costs.