Maryland case law › Reichard v. Davis

Reichard v. Davis

95 Md. 740 (1902) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: RemandedBoyd, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to the Izer litigation (ante, p. 451). The petition filed by Reichard and Davis simply referred to the grounds stated in the petition filed by Nancy E. Izer and Charles B. Izer. Because the Court held in the Izer case that their petition was defective, the Court held that this petition must also fall. However, the Orphans' Court had ordered that two of the issues submitted by the executors be sent to the Circuit Court, and the executors were in part responsible for that order. Consequently, the Court directed that each party pay one-half of the costs, including the cost of making up the record in this Court. The case was remanded so that the petition could be amended if desired. The Court did not address the merits of the petition beyond its incorporation of the defective Izer petition.
Questions presented
  • Whether the petition filed by Reichard and Davis, which simply refers to the petition filed by Nancy E. Izer and Charles B. Izer for the grounds upon which it is based, is defective because the Izer petition was held defective.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Opinion by Boyd, J., • As the petition in this case simply refers to that filed by Nancy E Izer and Charles B. Izer for the grounds upon which it is based, and as the Court, held in the case in which the Izers are parties, ante, p. 451, that their petition is defective, this must fall with it. But as the Orphans’ Court ordered that two of the issues submitted by the executors be sent to the Circuit Court and the executors are in part responsible for that order, the Court directed that each party pay one-half of the costs including making up the record in this Court. The case was remanded so the petition can be amended if desired.