Maryland case law › Reynolds v. Juliet

Reynolds v. Juliet

14 Md. 118 (1859) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTcuk, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on an exception to the trial court's rejection of a prayer offered by the defendant. The record was barren of any testimony or statement of facts, so the appellate court could not assess the legal sufficiency or relevancy of any evidence regarding assets. The Court noted that if no proof of assets was offered, a question as to the onus of proof might arise, but it could not pass on that question in the present state of the record. The Court also observed that it did not appear how the petitioners claimed their freedom—whether by will or deed of manumission—nor what relation the appellant stood to the cause. Relying on Burtles v. State, use of Turner, 4 Md. 277, the Court presumed, in the absence of testimony, that the trial court acted properly in refusing the instruction. The judgment was affirmed. The Court cited Allein v. Sharp, 7 G. & J. 96,
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in refusing the defendant's prayer, in the absence of any testimony in the record.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tcuk, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The exception contains nothing' but a prayer offered by the defendant, which was rejected. According to the case of Burtles vs. The State, use of Turner, 4 Md Rep., 277, we must, in the absence of testimony, intend that the court acted properly-in refusing the instruction. If there was any proof on the subject of assets, it ought t © have been set out to enable the court to pass upon its legal .sufficiency and relevancy to the issues on trial.

If, as we presume from the prayer, there was none whatever offered, a 121 question as to the onus of proof might arise, on which we cannot pass in the present state of the record. It does not appear how the petitioners claimed their freedom, whether by will or deed of manumission; nor in what relation the appellant stood to the cause. See Allein vs. Sharp, 7 G. & J., 96 . Wilson vs. Barnet, 8 G. & J., 159 ,and 9 G. & J., 158 .

Decided July 15th, 1859. Judgment affirmed.