Maryland case law › Richmond v. DISTRICT COURT OF MARYLAND

Richmond v. DISTRICT COURT OF MARYLAND

412 Md. 672 (2010) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Vacated✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam order, the Court of Appeals of Maryland addressed whether a declaratory judgment action seeking to establish a right to Public Defender representation at initial appearances before District Court Commissioners could proceed without joining the Public Defender as a party, and whether the Circuit Court properly certified a class action without first hearing from the Public Defender. The Appellants, representing a class of indigent persons, filed a complaint for declaratory judgment against the District Court of Maryland, asserting that indigent defendants have a right to be represented by the Public Defender during their initial appearance before a District Court Commissioner. The Public Defender was not joined as a party. The Circuit Court accepted the parties' agreement that the case satisfied the prerequisites for class certification under Md. Rule 2-231. The Court of
Questions presented
  • Whether the Circuit Court should have dismissed the Complaint pursuant to Md. Rule 2-211(a) because the Public Defender was not joined as a party.
  • Whether the Circuit Court should have accepted the parties' agreement that the issues satisfied the prerequisites of Md. Rule 2-231 before the Public Defender had the opportunity to be heard on class certification and on whether the Public Defender is obligated to represent an indigent defendant during his or her initial appearance before a District Court Commissioner.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM ORDER. The Appellants in this case have sought a declaratory judgment that they and the class of indigent persons they represent have the right to be represented by the Public Defender during an initial appearance before a District Court Commissioner. The Appellants have not, however, joined the Public Defender as a party. Under these circumstances, the Circuit Court should have dismissed the Complaint pursuant to Md. Rule 2-211(a).

Although the parties have agreed that the issues presented in this case satisfy the prerequisites of Md. Rule 2-231, the Circuit Court should not have accepted that agreement before the Public Defender had the opportunity to be heard on the issue of whether this case should be maintained as a class action, as well as on the issue of whether the Public Defender is obligated to represent an indigent defendant during his or her initial appearance before a District Court Commissioner. It is therefore, this 5th day of March, 2010, by the Court of Appeals of Maryland, a majority concurring: ORDERED that the judgment of the Circuit Court be and is hereby VACATED; and it is further ORDERED that this case be remanded to the Circuit Court; and it is further 673 ORDERED that the Circuit Court, as soon as is reasonably practical, enter a conditional order of refusal to certify this case as a class action; and it is further ORDERED that the Circuit Court enter an Order dismissing the Complaint on April 6, 2010, unless by that date Appellants have joined the Public Defender as a party in this case. Mandate to issue forthwith.