Maryland case law › Ridley v. State

Ridley v. State

220 Md. 182 (1959) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted of the unauthorized use of a motor vehicle under Code (1957), Article 27, Section 349. The sole question on appeal was whether the appellant possessed the criminal intent necessary to sustain the conviction when he physically used an automobile belonging to another. The Court, in a per curiam opinion, framed the issue as one of fact: whether the appellant had the requisite criminal intent at the time of the unauthorized use. The Court noted that the state of a man's mind is as much a question of fact as the state of his digestion, quoting Tufts v. Poore, 219 Md. 1, 11. After carefully examining the record, the Court held that the evidence and permissible inferences therefrom fully supported the trial judge's finding that the appellant possessed criminal intent when using the automobile. The Court relied on Anello v. State, 201 Md. 164, for the proposition that
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant, who was convicted of the unauthorized use of a motor vehicle under the Code (1957), Article 27, Section 349, possessed criminal intent, a necessary element of the offense, when he was physically using an automobile belonging to another.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The sole question involved in this appeal is whether the appellant, who was convicted of the unauthorized use of a motor vehicle under the Code (1957), Article 27, Section 349, possessed criminal intent, a necessary element of the offense, Anello v. State, 201 Md. 164 , when he was physically using an automobile belonging to another. The question of his intention, of course, involved a question of fact. We recently quoted from a celebrated statement of Lord Bowen in an action of deceit to the effect that the state oí a man’s mind is as much a question of fact as the state of his digestion.

Tufts v. Poore, 219 Md. 1, 11 . We have carefully examined the record; the evidence, and permissible inferences therefrom, fully support the finding of the trial judge that the appellant possessed criminal intent when using the automobile. Anello v. State, supra. Judgment affirmed.