Maryland case law › Robinson v. Cator

Robinson v. Cator

78 Md. 72 (1893) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedRoberts, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to the preceding case and involves the assignment of a life insurance policy issued to Faulkner for $1,000. The material distinction is that the association never assented to the assignment to Mr. Robinson. The Court, speaking through Roberts, J., relied on its prior decision in New York Life Ins. Co. v. Flack, 3 Md. 353, which held that in fire policies a condition requiring the underwriter's assent to assignment is valid because the character of the insured is material, but that no such reason obtains in life insurance. The Court affirmed the view that knowledge of the assignment is only important to prevent double payment to assignee and legal representatives. Applying that reasoning and the reasons assigned in the preceding case, the Court affirmed the decree. The opinion is brief and does not set out additional facts or procedural history beyond the referenc
Questions presented
  • Whether the assignment of a life insurance policy is valid without the assent of the insurer.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Roberts, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case is similar to the preceding case in all material respects, save that in this case the association never 73 gave its assent to the assignment to Mr. Robinson of the policy issued to Faulkner for the sum of one thousand dollars. This Court held in the case of the New York Life Ins. Co. vs. Flack, 3 Md., 353 , that “knowledge of the assignment could only be important to it in one view: to prevent the possibility of its being compelled to pay both the assignee and the legal representatives of the insured.

In fire policies there is, generally, a condition, that any assignment will he void without the assent of the underwriters be first obtained. The reason of this obvious. A fire policy may be underwritten for one person, when it would not be for another. In all such cases, the character for integrity and caution of the party constitute important considerations.

While the character of one person would be a complete guaranty that he would not fire his own house or goods, the character of his assignee might furnish no such assurance, and therefore it is that in fire policies the assent of the underwriters is indispensable to the validity of the assignment. No such reason obtains in the case of an insurance on human life.” (Decided 21st June, 1893.) Affirming this view, and for the reasons assigned in the preceding case, we affirm the decree. Decree affirmed.