Maryland case law › Rosenberg v. Moore

Rosenberg v. Moore

11 Md. 376 (1857) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C.J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on an appeal from an order of the circuit court. The complainants (creditors) filed an original and amended bill challenging a deed of trust executed by Blondheim for the benefit of his creditors. The bill alleged that the deed did not convey all of Blondheim's property, and that the property was in imminent danger because it had been placed in the care of a person of notoriously bad character, and the defendants and the custodian refused to allow an inventory to be made, which would deprive the creditors of proof of any loss. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, affirmed the circuit court's order. The Court held that the case made by the bill justified the circuit court's action. The Court reasoned that the deed assailed did not, in words, convey all of Blondheim's property; while the property conveyed for the benefit of
Questions presented
  • Whether the deed of trust for the benefit of creditors was valid when it did not, in words, convey all of the debtor's property.
  • Whether the bill's allegations of imminent danger to the property justified the circuit court's action.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand;; C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. We aré of opinion that the case made by the original and amended bill, justified the action of the circuit court. ' The deed assailed/ does not, in words, convey all the property of Blondheim; that which it did convey, for the benefit of his creditors, may, indeed, have been all, but its terms are not inconsistent with the fact that he may have retained a considerable amount of property, real and personal. Whilst the law authorizes a debtor to make a deed, such as the one in this case, it yet demands it should be a conveyance of all his property, without any reservation, whatsoever, to himself. Green 381 & Trammell vs. Trieber, 3 Md. Rep., 11 ; and Sangston vs. Gaither, 3 Md. Rep., 40 .

This is not plainly manifest on the face of the deed. It should have affirmatively so appeared. As was said in the case of Malcolm vs. Hodges, 8 Md. Rep., 418 , tbe validity of a deed of trust, for the benefit of creditors, must be determined by the deed itself, without reference to extrinsic facts; such an assignment, to be valid, must convey all the property of the debtor, and, in terms, dedicate the whole for the benefit of his creditors. Besides, the bill shows the property to be in imminent danger.

It avers, that it has been placed under the care of a person of notoriously bad character, and that, by the refusal of the defendants, and the custodian of the goods, to allow an inventory to be made, that if loss should occur, complainants and the other creditors will be deprived of the necessary proof to show the extent of such loss. These circumstances, we think, bring this case within the rules laid down in the case of Blondheim, et al., vs. Moore, et al., decided at this term, (ante 365.) Order affirmed, and cause remanded.