Maryland case law › Rossen & Cohen v. Novak

Rossen & Cohen v. Novak

259 Md. 508 (1970) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a per curiam opinion by the Maryland Court of Appeals dismissing an appeal for failure to transmit the record within the time prescribed by the Maryland Rules. The order for appeal was filed January 19, 1970. At the appellant's request, the trial court extended the time for transmitting the record to May 1, 1970, and the record was actually transmitted April 28, 1970. However, Maryland Rule 825 b provides that the lower court 'shall not extend the time [for transmitting the record] to a day more than ninety days from the date after the first order for appeal is filed.' Because the record was transmitted more than ninety days after the appeal was filed, the extension was beyond the trial court's authority. The Court further noted that the delay was not occasioned by 'the neglect, omission or inability of the clerk of the lower court, the court stenographer or appellee' as specifie
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal must be dismissed because the record was transmitted more than ninety days after the date the first order for appeal was filed, contrary to Maryland Rule 825 b.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The order for appeal in this case was filed on January 19, 1970. Pursuant to the request of the appellant, the trial court extended the time for transmitting the record 509 to May 1,1970. The record was actually transmitted April 28, 1970.

Maryland Rule 825 b provides “the lower court shall not extend the time [for transmitting the record] to a day more than ninety days from the date after the first order for appeal is filed.” The record was transmitted more than 90 days after the date the appeal was filed. It does not appear that the delay was occasioned by “the neglect, omission or inability of the clerk of the lower court, the court stenographer or appellee” as specified in Maryland Rule 825 d. Accordingly, the appeal must be dismissed. Goldman v. Tauber, 258 Md. 174 , 265 A. 2d 225 (1970).

If the case had been considered on its merits, we would have affirmed the decree of the trial court. Appeal dismissed; appellants to pay the costs.