Maryland case law › Rother v. Trustees of Sharp Street Station of the Methodist Episcopal Church

Rother v. Trustees of Sharp Street Station of the Methodist Episcopal Church

85 Md. 528 (1897) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPage, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellee, the Trustees of Sharp Street Station of the Methodist Episcopal Church, filed a bill seeking a declaration that its title to certain property was good and marketable and to compel the appellant, Rother, to specifically perform his contract to make a loan on the property. The same matter had previously been before the Court in 83 Md. 289, where relief was denied because (1) the heirs of John Sinclair and James Carey, grantors in the deeds of 1811, 1833, and 1802, were not made parties, and (2) the character of the appellees' possession was not sufficiently shown. On this second appeal, the Court found both objections met: the Carey heirs were made parties by actual notice, summons, or publication, and the Sinclair heirs, being non-resident and unknown despite utmost diligence, were notified by publication. The only remaining question was whether the evidence established a cl
Questions presented
  • Does all the evidence as we now have it, establish a clear title in fee, in the appellees, by adversary possession?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Page, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The bill in this case was filed by the appellee to obtain a declaration that the title to the property in question is good and marketable, and to require the appellant to specifically execute his contract. The same matter has been before this Court once before; its decision will be found in 83 Md. 289 . The relief asked for then, and now, was refused in that case for the reasons : 1st.

The heirs of John Sinclair, the grantor in the deeds of the 30th of May, 1811, and of the 30th of August, 1833, and the heirs of James Carey, the grantor in the deed of the 15th of May, 1802, were not made parties to the proceeding; and 2nd. Upon the evidence disclosed by the record, the character of the appellees’ possession of the premises was not sufficiently made to appear. It is contended here that both of these objections are now fully met. The appellant admits in his answer, “ that if the proof herein taken shall show that all the parties having any interest in the determination of the question of the title are parties,” and if this Court shall determine the appellees’ title to be good and marketable, he is ready to make the loan.

The bill shows that John Sinclair has long since departed this life, being at the time a non-resident of the State, and that his heirs are unknown to the appellees, although they have used the “ utmost diligence to discover them.” Notice by publication was made as to them in pursuance of an order of the Court. It is quite sufficient to say concerning the heirs of James Carey, they have all been made parties, and are now before the Court by actual notice, by summons, or by order of publication. There is in this case proof other 530 than that contained in the first, and the only question that now remains for us to determine is, does all the evidence as we now have it, establish a clear title in fee, in the appellees, by adversary possession. (Decided April 1st, 1897).

The appellees were incorporated in 1832. On the 18th of July of that year, at a meeting of the male members of the church, held in pursuance of the Act of Assembly, the corporation was organized and a certificate thereof filed for record. By that it appears certain trustees were appointed, and it was declared that “ all the lands and tenements ” and “ all other property of the said church was vested in the corporation, with full power in the latter, with the consent of two-thirds of the male members, to sell, lease, convey or otherwise dispose of it.” The evidence shows that declaration is applicable to the property affected by these proceedings, and amounts to an emphatic statement of a claim and intention to hold the same hostile to and clear of all the trusts contained in the several deeds of Carey and Sinclair. And ever since that date the trustees have so held it.

Without the leave, license or permission of any one, but claiming in their own right, the trustees mentioned in the certificate and their successors duly appointed have continuously maintained an open, notorious and exclusive possession, and used and enjoyed it for any and every purpose, to which they saw fit to devote it, within the powers conferred on the corporation which they represent. Such a possession having continued uninterruptedly for more than twenty years, is quite sufficient to afford the presumption of a deed conferring upon the appellees a title in fee, good and marketable. Sadtler v. Peabody H. Co., 66 Md. 4. Decree affirmed.