Maryland case law › Rutherford v. Pope

Rutherford v. Pope

15 Md. 579 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a motion to dismiss the appeal. The appellant sought review of an order of the Court of Common Pleas striking out a judgment. The record showed that the motion to strike out the judgment was made during the same term at which the judgment was rendered. The appellant's counsel attempted to present certain rules of the Court of Common Pleas as part of his exceptions, but these rules were not certified by the judge or otherwise authenticated. The Court of Appeals held that it could not consider the rules because they were not properly before it. The Court further held that until the lapse of the term, the judgment was subject to the control of the court, and whether the judge acted wisely in striking out the judgment was not a matter for the appellate court to determine on this appeal. The Court cited Ellicott v. Eustace, 6 Md. 508, and cases th
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal should be dismissed because the record does not properly show the rules of the Court of Common Pleas applicable to its action.
  • Whether the Court of Appeals can consider rules of the lower court that were not certified by the judge or otherwise authenticated.
  • Whether the trial court's action in striking out a judgment during the same term it was rendered is reviewable on appeal.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. The motion, in this case, to dismiss the appeal, must prevail. There is nothing in the record which can be relied upon by this court to show what are the rules of the court of Common Pleas, applicable to its action in the premises. It is true, the appellant’s counsel, in what he terms his exceptions, has set out certain rules as those of that court, but they are not certified to as such by the judge, or otherwise, and of course cannot be taken as such by this court.

The record shows that the motion to strike out the judgment was made during the sa,me term at which it was rendered. Until the lapse of the term, it was subject to the control of the court. Whether the judge, in striking out the judgment, acted wisely or not, it is not for this court to determine on this appeal, the matter not being before it. See - the case of Ellicolt vs. Eustace, 6 Md. Rep., 508 , and the cases there referred to.

Appeal dismissed.