Maryland case law › Sample v. State

Sample v. State

235 Md. 554 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryIn a nonjury trial in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, Alexander Sample was convicted of first degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. On appeal, he raised a single issue: whether the evidence was sufficient to convince the trial court beyond a reasonable doubt that the homicide was committed with deliberation and premeditation. The Court of Appeals affirmed, applying Maryland Rule 886 a, which provides that a trial court's finding of fact in a nonjury case will not be set aside unless clearly erroneous. The Court noted that the appellant conceded he armed himself with a butcher knife when he left home to look for the victim, who had recently fought with the appellant's brother. Testimony showed that when the appellant found the victim, he waved the knife and struck at him but missed; the victim fled down an alley, was pursued by the appellant, and in a second fight was stabbed
Questions presented
  • Whether there was sufficient evidence upon which the trial court could be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the homicide was committed with deliberation and premeditation.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The appellant, Alexander Sample, was sentenced to life imprisonment after being convicted of first degree murder in a nonjury trial in the Criminal Court of Baltimore. On this appeal he raises only the question whether there was sufficient evidence upon which the trial court could be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt, that the homicide was committed with deliberation and premeditation. We think this question must be answered in the affirmative.

The finding of fact by the trial court, sitting without a jury, that the evidence showed deliberation and premeditation beyond a reasonable doubt, wdll not be set aside by this Court unless clearly erroneous. Maryland Rule 886 a; Cummings v. State, 223 Md. 606, 610-611 . It was conceded that the appellant armed himself with a butcher knife when he left his home to look for the victim, who, a short time previously, had been involved in a fight with the appellant’s brother. There was testimony that when the appellant found the victim he waved the 556 knife and struck at him, but apparently missed.

The victim then ran down an alley but was pursued by the appellant and another fight ensued during which the victim was stabbed twice. Several witnesses testified that they saw the appellant standing over the victim in the alley with a knife in his hand, and one witness stated that he saw the appellant “bring the knife up and down about two or three times”. This evidence, and the proper and rational inferences therefrom, were such that the trial court could be fairly convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the appellant had acted with premeditation and deliberation, and we cannot say that it was clearly in error in so finding. Cf.

Hyde v. State, 228 Md. 209, 215-217 . The appellant argues that the incident happened too quickly for him to have had time to form a design to kill. But we have said, “if the killing is not the instant effect of impulse, if there is hesitation or doubt to be overcome, a choice made as a result of thought, however short the struggle between the intention and the act, the crime is sufficient to be characterized as deliberate and premeditated murder.” Faulcon v. State, 211 Md. 249, 258 . In the instant case the trial judge found that the design to kill originated when the victim ran away and the appellant pursued him, stabbing him not once, but twice.

Again, we cannot say that the trial judge’s finding was clearly in error. Judgment affirmed.