Maryland case law › Scheydt v. Pratt Properties, Inc.

Scheydt v. Pratt Properties, Inc.

229 Md. 31 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe Board of County Commissioners of Anne Arundel County rezoned a 41-acre tract near Glen Burnie from agricultural to light industrial, finding a substantial change in the character of the neighborhood since comprehensive zoning was adopted in 1952. Nearby residents who had opposed the application sued in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County to enjoin the rezoning. The case was submitted on the record from the County Commissioners. The protestants presented testimony from neighboring landowners and civic association officers that the change would devaluate nearby properties, increase traffic hazards, and constitute 'spot' zoning, and that the property could be developed residentially. The appellee presented testimony from an industrial realtor, a builder, and three nearby property owners establishing a developing complex of major highways with elaborate interchanges in the immediat
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence of change in the character of the neighborhood was sufficient to render the question of rezoning fairly debatable, so that the trial court properly refused to enjoin the reclassification.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On the ground that there had been substantial change in the character of the neighborhood since the adoption of comprehensive zoning in 1952, the Board of County Commissioners of Anne Arundel County granted rezoning from agricultural to light industrial of a 41 acre tract fronting on Quarterfield Road and on Old Stage Road, near Glen Burnie, on application of the appellee, the contract purchaser of the tract. Certain nearby residents, who had opposed the application, filed suit in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County to enjoin the rezoning. The case was submitted to the court on the record sent up by the County Commissioners.

The protestants had produced testimony by neighboring landowners and officers of interested civic associations to the effect that the change would devaluate properties in the neighborhood, increase traffic hazards, and constitute “spot” zoning, and that the subject property could in fact be developed for residential use. On the other hand, testimony was given on behalf of the appellee by an industrial realtor, a builder, and three individuals owning nearby properties. In regard to change in the character of the neighborhood, their testimony established a developing complex of major highways, with elaborate interchanges, in the immediate vicinity, and a general increase in traffic. The recently constructed Glen Burnie dual-lane by-pass adjoins one side of the subject property. 33 It was shown that the State Roads Commission has adopted plans to relieve the chronic traffic bottle-neck at Ritchie Highway and Mountain Road by extending the latter to' the bypass, near the property in question.

It was also shown that the proximity of the tract to Friendship Airport has created serious problems of noise and obnoxious odors, especially since the advent of jet plane traffic in recent years. This factor was said to have rendered it impossible to obtain VA or FHA financing for residential development of the property, and to have prevented several attempted sales for that purpose. In addition to finding substantial change in the neighborhood, the County Commissioners determined that the tract was suitable for light manufacturing uses and that the rezoning would not devaluate nearby property. The trial court found that these matters were at least fairly debatable and refused to enjoin the reclassification.

We see no error here. The determination of whether sufficient change has occurred to justify reclassification must, be made in the first instance by the appropriate zoning authority. If the evidence was sufficient to bring the question within the realm of the fairly debatable, the court cannot substitute its own judgment for that of the zoning authority. Didlake v. Poteet, 228 Md. 588, 180 A. 2d 828 (1962); County Council v. Gendleman, 227 Md. 491, 177 A. 2d 687 (1962).

In the case before us, the evidence of change was sufficient to render the question fairly debatable. Decree affirmed; costs to be paid by appellants.