Maryland case law › Shenberger v. State

Shenberger v. State

234 Md. 363 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, Shenberger, was convicted by Judge Sodaro, sitting without a jury, of assault with intent to murder his estranged wife. The only contention on appeal was that the evidence was insufficient to permit an inference that the assault was made with an intent to murder. The State's evidence showed that the appellant lured his estranged wife into the cellar of her home, placed a loaded gun (purchased the day before) at her ear, and told her that after he used it on her he would turn it on himself. A neighbor returning borrowed shampoo distracted the appellant, and the wife knocked the gun from his hand. According to the wife, the appellant then hit her, kicked her, and struggled with her in an effort 'to point the gun back towards me.' The Court of Appeals held that if the trier of facts believed the wife and neighbor, as he seemingly did, he properly could have found that the poi
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence was sufficient to permit an inference that the assault made on his wife was with an intent to murder.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The only contention now made by the appellant is that the evidence was insufficient to permit an inference that the assault he made on his wife was with an intent to murder, the crime with which he was charged and of which Judge Sodaro, sitting without a jury, found him guilty. There was testimony that appellant lured his estranged wife into the cellar of her home and then put a loaded gun, which he had bought the day before, at her ear, telling her that after he had used it on her he was going to turn it on himself. At this point a neighbor, who was returning shampoo she had borrowed from the wife, distracted the appellant and the wife was able to knock the gun from her husband’s hand, whereupon, according to the wife, he hit her and kicked her and struggled with her in an effort “to point the gun back towards me.” 365 If the trier of facts believed the facts to be as the wife and the neighbor said they were, as he seemingly did, he properly could have found that the pointing of the deadly weapon at the head and the expressed intention to kill, followed by the struggle to again point the gun at the wife established the necessary elements of the crime of assault with intent to murder.

Had death ensued, the evidence would clearly have supported a finding of malice and of commission of the crime of murder. Marks v. State, 230 Md. 108, 112 ; Beall v. State, 203 Md. 380 . Judgment affirmed.