Maryland case law › Smith v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Smith v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

197 Md. 684 (1951) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DeniedMarkell, J.✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner, imprisoned under sentences aggregating fifty years and six months for robbery (two cases), robbery with a deadly weapon, and assault, sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus. He alleged that his constitutional rights were violated because the trial court failed to appoint counsel for him at trial. The Court of Appeals noted that petitioner not only could have raised, but actually did raise, this contention on direct appeal through counsel appointed for that purpose, and the judgment was affirmed in Smith v. State, 180 Md. 529, 25 A.2d 681. The Court further held that any other contentions now made—such as failure of the court to advise him that he could conduct his own defense or of his right to appeal—if not made on appeal, could have been made then and cannot be heard on habeas corpus, citing Loughran v. Warden, 192 Md. 719, 64 A.2d 712. The Court
Questions presented
  • Whether petitioner's constitutional rights were violated by failure of the court to appoint counsel for him at his trial, where this contention was already raised and decided on direct appeal.
  • Whether contentions not raised on direct appeal, such as failure of the court to advise petitioner that he could conduct his own case or of his right to appeal, can be heard on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Markell, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application for leave to appeal from denial of a writ of habeas corpus. Petitioner is imprisoned under sentences aggregating fifty years and six months for robbery (two cases), robbery with á deadly weapon, and assault. He alleges that his constitutional rights were violated by failure of the court to appoint counsel 685 for him at his trial.

He not only could have made, but did make, this contention on appeal to this court through counsel appointed by the court for the purpose of appeal. The judgment was affirmed. Smith v. State, 180 Md. 529 , 25 A. 2d 681 . If any other contentions now made, e. g., failure of the court to advise him (a) “that he could conduct his own case in his own defense” or (b) of “his right to appeal”, were not made on appeal, they could have been made then and cannot be heard on habeas corpus.

Loughran v. Warden, 192 Md. 719 , 64 A. 2d 712 . Indeed, these contentions seem self-contradictory. Application denied, with costs.