Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBoyd, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to another appeal between the same parties, Snook v. Munday, also decided by the Court of Appeals. The Court, in a brief per curiam-style opinion by Boyd, J., held that its decision in the preceding case controlled the disposition here. The order of the Orphans' Court of Washington County, passed on November 10, 1899, was therefore reversed. The Court noted that there was no occasion to insert the petition of Elizabeth Munday and the copy of the will of John Munday into the record in this case, as those documents had already been included in the record of the companion case. Because the parties had unnecessarily created two records, the Court exercised its discretion over costs: each party was required to pay one-half of the costs in the Court of Appeals, including the costs of the copy transmitted to that Court, while the appellee was to pay the costs below. The
Boyd, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. It follows from what we have said in the preceding case between these parties, that the order of the Orphans’ Court of Washington County, passed on the ioth day of November, 1899, must be reversed. But as there was no occasion to have the petition of Elizabeth Munday and the copy of the will of John Munday inserted in the record in this case, as they were in the other record, each party will be required to pay one-half of the costs in this Court, including the costs of the copy transmitted to this Court, the costs below to be paid by the appellee. There was indeed no necessity to have two records.
Order reversed, each party to pay one-half of the costs in this Court, the appellee to pay the costs in the lower Court.