Maryland case law › Snyder v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Snyder v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

214 Md. 606 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPrescott✓ Good law
SummaryThe petitioner, convicted of statutory rape and perverted sexual practice in Washington County and sentenced to twelve years in the Maryland Penitentiary, sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Cullen of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City. He raised five contentions: (1) denial of the right to have all his witnesses present at trial; (2) incompetent counsel; (3) that his confession was secured by false misrepresentation and parts added after signing; (4) that he is illiterate; and (5) that he is innocent. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam-style opinion by Judge Prescott, held that none of these contentions had merit in habeas corpus proceedings. On the first, the Court relied on Legrand v. Warden for the rule that a claim of denial of the right to summon witnesses, even if true, is not a basis for habeas corpus. On the second, the Court held that
Questions presented
  • Whether the petitioner was denied the right to have all of his witnesses present at the time of his trial.
  • Whether the petitioner's attorney was incompetent.
  • Whether the confession obtained from him was secured by 'false misrepresentation,' and parts of it had been added after he signed it.
  • Whether the petitioner is illiterate.
  • Whether the petitioner is innocent.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Prescott, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The petitioner asks leave to appeal from a denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Cullen of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City. He was convicted of statutory rape and perverted sexual practice in Washington County and sentenced to a total of twelve years in the Maryland Penitentiary, to date from November 22, 1954. The petitioner contends: (1) that he was denied the right to have all of his witnesses present at the time of his trial; (2) that his attorney was incompetent; (3) that the confession obtained from him was secured by “false misrepresentation,” and parts of it had been added after he signed it; (4) that he is illiterate; and (5) that he is innocent.

None of these has merit in this proceeding. (1). This Court held in Legrand v. Warden, 205 Md. 662 , 109 A. 2d 908 , that a contention by the petitioner that he was denied the right to summons witnesses in his defense, even if true, would not constitute a basis for granting a writ of habeas corpus. (2).

In the absence of an allegation or showing that the petitioner complained to the trial court of his counsel’s alleged incompetence, ineptness or lack of interest in his cause, or that there was fraud or bad faith on the part of, or collusion with, any official of the State, a claim that the petitioner’s counsel was incompetent does not justify the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus. Legrand v. Warden, supra; Bergen v. Warden, 208 Md. 677 , 119 A. 2d 438 . (3). This Court frequently has held that attacks on the competency, admissibility or sufficiency of the evidence cannot serve as the basis for the issu 608 anee of the writ requested.

Davis v. Warden, 208 Md. 675 , 119 A. 2d 365 ; Thompson v. Warden, 209 Md. 628 , 120 A. 2d 200 . (4). The fact that a petitioner is illiterate, standing by itself, is not a sufficient ground to issue the writ of habeas corpus. It will be noted in this regard that in this case he was represented by counsel.

(5). This Court has repeatedly held that the question of the guilt or innocence of the petitioner cannot be retried in habeas corpus proceedings. Walker v. Warden, 209 Md. 654 , 121 A. 2d 714 . Application denied, with costs.