Maryland case law › Somervell v. Hunt
Somervell v. Hunt
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from an action against a defendant who held a negro in custody under a paper purporting to be a commitment issued by a justice of the peace. The commitment was not under seal. The county court determined that because the warrant of commitment was not under seal, the action would not lie against the defendant. The plaintiff excepted to the county court's opinion and direction to the jury. On appeal, the general court affirmed the judgment. The opinion is extremely brief and does not set forth the underlying facts beyond the nature of the action and the defect in the commitment. The court held that the paper purporting to be a commitment was void, that the negro was not lawfully in the defendant's custody, and that the defendant was not liable to the action or any damages to the plaintiff in the manner and form as the action was prosecuted. The court's reasoning appears to
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the warrant of commitment by the justice was void because it was not under seal, and whether on that account the action would lie.
The Court were of opinion, and So directed the jury, that the paper purporting to be a commitment was void, and that the said negro was not lawfully in the custody of the defendant; and that the defendant is not liable to this action, or any damages to the plaintiff, in the manner and form as the said action is prosecuted. The plaintiff excepted to this opinion and direction of the court. The objection in this case was, that the warrant of 115 commitment by the justice was not under seal, and the county court determined, that on that account, the action would not lie. Martin, (Attorney-General,) for the appellant.
Pinkney, for the appellee. The general court affirmed the judgment.