Maryland case law › Spurrier's Lessee v. Yieldhall

Spurrier's Lessee v. Yieldhall

2 Md. 173 (1787) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Modified✓ Good law
SummaryIn this 1787 ejectment action, Rezin Spurrier's Lessee obtained a judgment and writ of possession at May term 1786 against Benjamin Yieldhall. Thereafter, Upton Scott filed an affidavit stating that at the time the ejectment suit was commenced, he was in possession of 9 1/4 acres of the land for which the ejectment was brought, that no copy of the declaration in ejectment was served upon him, and that he claimed the 9 1/4 acres as tenant in fee-simple. The court issued a rule on the plaintiff to show cause why the judgment and execution should not be set aside as to those acres and why Scott should not be admitted as a defendant. Upon consideration, the court ordered that the judgment be struck out as to the 9 1/4 acres claimed by Upton Scott. The court's ruling rests on the principle that a person in possession of land claiming a freehold estate, who was not made a party to the ejectmen
Questions presented
  • Whether a judgment in ejectment should be set aside as to a portion of the land where a person in possession claiming a fee-simple estate was not served with the declaration and was not a party to the suit?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

At this term, on the 12th of May, it was ruled by the Court, “ that Rezin Spurrier show cause, this term, why the writ of possession and judgment entered at May term, 1786, for his lessee, against Benjamin YieldhalL should not be set aside.” And on the 21st of May, in the same term, “ it appearing to the Court, by the affidavit of Upton Scott, that at the time of commencing the suit of Rezin Spurrier’s Lessee against Benjamin Yield-hall, the said Upton Scott was in possession of 9 1-4 acres of the land, for which the ejectment was brought, and that no copy of the declaration in ejectment was served upon him, and that the said Scott claims the said 9 1-4 acres of land as tenant in fee-simple, and a rule having been served on the plaintiff, to show cause, &c. and the iMsap onUScott now praying that the judgment and cxe 174 cution be set aside, as to the said 9 1-4 acres, and that he be admitted defendant in this cause, as to the said acres. Ordered, that the judgment be struck out, as to the said 9 1-4 acres, claimed by the said Upton Scott”