Maryland case law › State Ex Rel. Fluskey v. Shipley

State Ex Rel. Fluskey v. Shipley

98 Md. 664 (1904) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedSchmucker, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal was heard together with State, use of Gemundt v. Shipley, No. 12 of the same docket, by agreement of the parties, because both suits arose from the same accident and the pleadings and evidence were identical in both cases. The Court of Appeals had already affirmed the judgment in Gemundt's case for the reasons set out in its opinion filed therein. Rather than repeat that reasoning, the Court stated it would affirm the judgment in the present case for the same reasons. The opinion is therefore entirely derivative: it decides no independent legal question, announces no new rule, and contains no separate analysis of facts or law. The only substantive content is the incorporation by reference of the Gemundt opinion and the affirmance of the judgment below. The disposition was 'Judgment affirmed with costs.' Because the opinion does not itself contain the court's reasoning, the le
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Schmucker, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This appeal comes before us upon the same record as the appeal in State, use of Gemundt v. Shipley, No. 12, of the present docket. The two suits were brought for damages for injuries occasioned by the same accident, and the pleadings and evidence are the same in both cases, and the appeals were by agreement heard together. We affirmed the judgment in Gemundt’s case for the reasons set out in our opinion filed therein.

Without repeating what we there said we will affirm the judgment in the present case for the same reasons. Judgment affirmed with costs.