Maryland case law › State v. Hendrickson

State v. Hendrickson

15 Md. 205 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe State of Maryland sued L. B. Smith and his sureties on his official bonds as collector of Allegany County for the years 1854 and 1855. The sureties pleaded payment and also that they had been released from all liability on the bonds by the Act of 1858, ch. 286. The State demurred to the latter defense. The trial court rendered judgment against the State, and the State appealed. The sole question before the Court of Appeals was whether the Act of 1858, ch. 286, was void under the 22nd section of Article 3 of the Maryland Constitution. The State argued that the Act was an unconstitutional appropriation or use of taxes levied to pay the public debt. The Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Tuck, J., rejected that argument. The Court characterized the Act as 'a mere release of claim on these bonds, and not as an appropriation, or use of the taxes levied to pay the public debt of the State
Questions presented
  • Whether the Act of 1858, ch. 286, is void in view of the 22nd sec. of Art. 3 of the Constitution?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. These appeals depend on the same question and may be decided together. The State sued L. B. Smith, and his sureties on his official bonds, as collector of Allegany county, for the years 1854 and 1855. The sureties, the present appellees, pleaded payment, and that they had been released by the Act of 1858, ch. 286, from all liability on these bonds, to which latter defence there was a demurrer, and j udgment having been rendered against the State, it appealed.

The question submitted for our consideration is, whether that act is void in view of the 22nd sec. of Art. 3 of the Constitution ? The argument, on the part of the State, suggests objections to this kind of legislation, which, if addressed to the consideration of the law makers, would doubtless have due weight, and this, probably, was done in the present instance; but they 208 affect the expediency of such Acts, and not the power of the Legislature to pass them. (Decided March 21st, 1860.) We regard this Act of Assembly as 'a mere release of claim on these bonds, and not as an appropriation, or use of the taxes levied to pay the public debt -of the State within the prohibition of the Constitution. That instrument did not, by the -clause relied upon, intend to deny to the Legislature the power to compromise and release claims of the State against its citizens, and, when exercised, we must suppose there was sufficient reason for it.

Judgments affirmed.