Maryland case law › State v. Ridgely

State v. Ridgely

2 Md. 120 (1785) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief report of a 1785 Maryland decision addresses several evidentiary questions arising in a criminal prosecution. The court allowed a declaration to be admitted as evidence. It further determined that it was improper, during examination of a witness, to mention what the witness had formerly sworn. On the question of a convict transported from Great Britain, the court held that parol evidence is admissible to prove that a man is a convict transported from Great Britain, and that such a convict cannot be restored to his credit without actual service during the seven years. Finally, the court held that the declarations of the deceased, made antecedent to the stroke which occasioned the death, are not admissible evidence, drawing a distinction between the declarations of the deceased and those of the prisoner: in the latter case, declarations are evidence because they tend to discover
Questions presented
  • Whether a declaration is admissible as evidence.
  • Whether it is improper to mention to the witness, in the course of the examination, what the witness swore formerly.
  • Whether parol evidence is admissible to prove a man a convict transported from Great Britain.
  • Whether a convict can be restored to his credit without actual service during the seven years.
  • Whether the declarations of the deceased, antecedent to the stroke which occasioned the death, are admissible evidence.
  • Whether a distinction exists between the declarations of the deceased and those of the prisoner.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court allowed the declaration, tp be evidence. The Court also determined it was improper to mention to the witñess, ifi the course of the examination, What the witné&S sWOrC formerly. The Court also determined, that path! evidence is admissible, to prové a man a convict, transported from Great -Arziamf nAd that a convict Cannot be restored to his credit, ‘ without actual service during the seven years. The Court also determined, that the declarations of the deceásed, antecedent to the stroke which occasioned the death, are not admissible evidence, and made á distinction between the declarations of the deceased and those of the prisoner.

In the latter case declarations are evidence, because they tend to discover quo animo the fact was committed.