Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedBoyd, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe State appealed after the court below sustained a demurrer to an indictment and entered judgment for the traverser (defendant). The appellee filed no brief; the State did. The Court of Appeals understood from the State's brief and the petition for writ of error that the demurrer had been sustained on the ground that Chapter 108 of the Acts of 1894 was unconstitutional as applied to offenses committed prior to its passage. The Court held that this precise question had already been decided to the contrary in Daniel H. Lynn v. State, decided at the same term. Because the lower court's ruling rested on a legal premise the Court of Appeals had rejected in Lynn, the judgment for the traverser could not stand. The Court therefore reversed the judgment and remanded the case so that the traverser could be tried. The opinion is brief and does not restate the facts of the offense, the indictment
Questions presented
Whether Chapter 108 of the Acts of 1894 is unconstitutional as to offenses committed prior to its passage.
Boyd, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. In this case the Court below sustained the demurrer to the indictment and entered judgment for the traverser. The appellee did not file a brief, but the State did. As we 84 understand from it and from the petition for a writ of error, that the ‘demurrer was sustained on the ground that the Act of 1894, chapter 108, was unconstitutional as to of-fences committed prior to its passage, it will only be necessary for us to refer to the opinion filed in the case of Daniel H. Lynn v. State, decided at this term, in which - we held the contrary; judgment must therefore be reversed and the -case remanded to the end that the traverser may be tried.
(Decided June 17th, 1896). Judgment reversed and a new 'trial ordered.