Maryland case law › State v. Stone

State v. Stone

3 Md. 115 (1792) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThe General Court issued a certiorari directed to the justices of Charles County Court. The Charles County Court allegedly disobeyed the state's process and proceeded after its delivery. The General Court ordered a summons against the said justices to show cause why they should not be held in contempt. Upon return of the summons, the chief justice appeared for himself and his associates. The General Court adjudged that the certiorari issued properly and legally, ought to have been obeyed by Charles County Court, and that for disobedience of the state's process and proceedings after delivery, the justices were guilty of a contempt of the state's process. It ordered an attachment against the chief justice, returnable the next term. An attachment issued June 19, 1792. Upon its return, the chief justice appeared in proper person and the associates by attorney. After hearing allegations, the
Questions presented
  • Whether the certiorari issued properly and legally and ought to have been obeyed by Charles County Court.
  • Whether the justices of Charles County Court were guilty of a contempt of the state's process for their disobedience of the said process and their proceedings after delivery thereof.
  • Whether the justices were entitled to an appeal to the Court of Appeals from the General Court's contempt adjudication and fines.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The general court ordered a summons against the said justices, to show cause, &ci which accordingly issued on the 6th of March, 1792. Upon the return of the said summons, the chief justice appeared on behalf of himself and his associates, and the general court “ adjudged that the certiorari, mentioned in the proceedings aforesaid, issued properly and legally, and ought to have heen obeyed by Charles county court; and that for their disobedience of the said state’s process, and their proceedings after the delivery thereof, they are guilty of a contempt of the state’s process. It is therefore adjudged and ordered by the court, that attachment issue against the chief justice for said contempt^ returnable the next term.” 117 An attachment accordingly issued the 19th of June, 1792, and upon the return of the said attachment, the chief justice appeared in proper person, and the associates appeared by Philip B. Key, their attorney, and, upon hearing their allegations, the general court fined the chief justice twenty shillings, current money, and fined each of the associate justices twenty shillings, current money, and costs, &c. The chief justice and associate justices prayed an appeal to the court of appeals; but the general court refused to grant the prayer.