Maryland case law › Stewart v. Clark

Stewart v. Clark

60 Md. 310 (1883) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedStone, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from the insolvency of a leasehold property owner. The appellant, Stewart, held a mortgage on the leasehold property. The insolvent trustees sold the leasehold property. The appellant claimed that the proceeds of the sale should be applied to pay the ground rents and taxes due on the leasehold property before the mortgage debt, or that the burden of those charges should fall on the other personal property of the insolvent estate. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Stone, held that when leasehold property is sold by insolvent trustees, the ground rents and taxes due thereon at the time of sale must be paid out of the proceeds of the sale before the purchaser can take good title, just as they would have been if the mortgagee had foreclosed and sold the property himself. The Court reasoned that it would be inequitable to relieve the leasehold property from these bu
Questions presented
  • Whether, when leasehold property is sold by insolvent trustees, the ground rents and taxes due thereon at the time of sale should be paid out of the proceeds of the sale before the purchaser takes title, or whether the leasehold property should be relieved from those charges and the burden cast upon the other personal property of the insolvent.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stone, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. If the appellant had. foreclosed his mortgage on the leasehold property himself, and sold it, it is clear that the taxes and ground rents due thereon at the time of such sale, must have been paid out of the proceeds of the sale before the purchaser took a good title thereto. When the -same leasehold property is sold by the insolvent trustees, we fail to see upon what principle of equity, the leasehold property should be relieved from the ground rents and taxes due upon it, and the burden cast upon the other personal property of the insolvent. The appellant had no lien on the personal property for his rents as he had not distrained.

Nor is there any 312 proof before us that any valid seizure by way of distraint,, by the Collector of the city had ever been made. (Decided 19th June, 1883.) Order affirmed.