Maryland case law › Stewart v. State

Stewart v. State

235 Md. 210 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted of robbery with a deadly weapon and sentenced to 20 years' confinement. On appeal, he raised three contentions. First, he argued that the trial court erred in admitting his confession because it was not voluntarily made. The Court of Appeals noted that three officers testified the statement was freely and voluntarily given, and the appellant offered only his own testimony to rebut the State's evidence. The court held that the admissibility of a confession is primarily a question for the trial court, and its determination will not be disturbed on appeal unless clearly erroneous, citing Abbott v. State, 231 Md. 462. Second, the appellant alleged insufficiency of the evidence. The court found that the two victims positively identified him at trial and testified as to his participation in the holdup. This testimony alone was sufficient, if believed, to sustain the
Questions presented
  • Did the trial court err in admitting a confession made by the appellant because it was not voluntarily made?
  • Was the evidence insufficient to sustain the conviction?
  • Did the trial judge err in sustaining the State's objection to certain evidence offered by the appellant?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

211 Per Curiam. There is little, if any, merit in this appeal. Appellant was convicted of robbery with a deadly weapon, and sentenced to 20 years’ confinement. He first complains that the court erred in admitting a confession made by him, because it was not voluntarily made.

Three officers testified that the statement was freely and voluntarily made, and appellant offered no testimony, other than his own, to rebut that offered by the State. The question of its admissibility was, primarily, one for the trial court, and its determination will not be disturbed on appeal, unless clearly erroneous. Abbott v. State, 231 Md. 462 . Appellant alleges an insufficiency of evidence to sustain the conviction.

The two victims of the robbery positively identified him at the trial, and testified as to his participation in the holdup. This testimony was sufficient, if believed by the trial court, to sustain the conviction without consideration of his confession; but when the victims’ testimony and appellant’s confession are both taken into account, they make this contention frivolous. Appellant finally argues that the trial judge erred in sustaining the State’s objection to certain evidence offered by him. It appears that on the night he was arrested, appellant made a statement admitting his participation in another holdup, not connected with the one for which he was being tried.

The following day, he signed the confession admitted against him at his trial. Appellant claims that another person admitted being guilty of having committed the first named holdup, after appellant made his statement relative thereto. He argues that this testimony would prove that he confessed having participated in the commission of a crime that he did not participate in, and if that confession were untrue, it necessarily follows that his confession in the instant case was untrue. There was no error here.

If inquiry into collateral matters of this character were permitted, it would cause an undue expenditure of time and the trial of issues not pertinent to the trial being conducted. Judgment affirmed.