Maryland case law › Tabor v. Swenson

Tabor v. Swenson

193 Md. 706 (1949) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryPer curiam denial of an application for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. Petitioner alleged that he was arrested without a warrant, illegally searched, and that his personal property was unlawfully seized and later introduced in evidence against him. The Court held that even if the arrest and detention were illegal, that does not permit a defendant to escape punishment when he was lawfully indicted, tried, and convicted, citing Davis v. Brady and Wright v. Swenson. The Court further held that the question whether articles obtained without a search warrant were offered in evidence cannot be retried on habeas corpus. Petitioner also alleged that he was unlawfully deprived of witnesses who would have testified in his behalf; the Court rejected this because he did not allege that summonses were issued for those witnesses or that he made his desire for witnesses kn
Questions presented
  • Whether an illegal arrest and detention permits a defendant to escape punishment when he was lawfully indicted, tried and convicted.
  • Whether the question of illegally seized articles being offered in evidence can be retried on habeas corpus.
  • Whether deprivation of witnesses constitutes a ground for habeas corpus relief where petitioner does not allege summonses were issued or that he made his desire for witnesses known to the trial court.
  • Whether deprivation of communication with an attorney until the day of trial, and ineffective assistance due to the attorney's intoxication, constitutes a ground for habeas corpus relief where petitioner does not allege he expressed dissatisfaction with counsel at trial.
  • Whether the question of guilt or innocence and the credibility and weight of the evidence can be tried on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM. This is an application for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. The petitioner alleges that he was arrested without a warrant and was illegally searched and his personal property unlawfully seized and subsequently introduced in evidence against him. Even if he was illegally arrested and held, he cannot for that reason escape punishment when lawfully indicted, tried and convicted.

Davis v. Brady, 188 Md. 113 , 51 A. 2d 827 ; Wright v. Swenson, Warden, 191 Md. 762 , 62 A. 2d 573 . Even if the articles obtained from him without a search warrant were offered in evidence against him, that question cannot be retried on habeas corpus. Wright v. Swenson, Warden, supra. He further alleges that he was unlawfully deprived of witnesses who would have testified in his behalf.

He does not allege that summonses were issued for these witnesses or that he made his desire for witnesses known to the trial court. Goodman v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary, 190 Md. 746 , 60 A. 2d 527 . He further alleges that he was deprived of any communication with an attorney until the day of his trial and on that day the attorney, whom he employed, was under the influence of strong intoxicants and therefore unable to properly represent him. He does not allege that he expressed any dissatisfaction with the services of his lawyer at the time of trial.

Goodman v. Warden of Maryland 708 Penitentiary, supra; Washington v. Warden, Maryland House of Correction, 191 Md. 760 , 61 A. 2d 561 . As to his contention that false testimony was offered against him, the question of guilt or innocence and credibility and weight of the evidence cannot be tried on habeas corpus. Rountree v. Wright, 189 Md. 292 , 55 A. 2d 847 , and cases there cited. Application denied, without costs