Maryland case law › Tate v. State

Tate v. State

239 Md. 697 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryTate, a sixteen-year-old who had completed the ninth grade and had been employed for several years, was indicted on a five-count indictment including robbery. He pleaded guilty in open court to the robbery count and was sentenced to three years by Judge Shirley B. Jones. On appeal, Tate contended that his guilty plea was not knowingly and understandingly made and was improperly received and ineffective because of his youth and because he did not understand the nature of the charge to which he was pleading. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, rejected these contentions, finding that the record refuted them. The Court emphasized the thorough colloquy conducted by Tate's attorney, in which Tate affirmed that he understood the reason he was in court, that he was charged with robbery, that the penalty ranged from three to ten years, that he had the right to plead not guilty and tak
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant's guilty plea was not knowingly and understandingly made and was improperly received and ineffective because of his youth and because he did not understand to what he was pleading guilty.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Pee Cueiam. The appellant Tate was indicted on a five-count indictment which included a count charging robbery. He plead guilty in open court to the robbery count and was sentenced to three years by Judge. Shirley B. Jones.

On this appeal he contends that his guilty plea was not knowingly and understanding^ made and was improperly received and ineffective because of his youth and because he did not understand1 to what he was pleading guilty. The record refutes the appellant’s claims. Tate was sixteen years old and had completed the ninth grade in school. He had been working for several years at an advertising company.

At the outset of the trial appellant’s attorney asked him the following questions: “Q. Are you aware of the reason you are in this court today? A. Yes. Q. You understand that you have been charged with robbery? A. Yes.

Q. Do you understand that the penalty if convicted of this crime is from three to ten years? A. Yes. Q. Now, Gregory, I have explained to you, haven’t I, that you have a right to plead not guilty and take a court or jury trial? Do you understand that?

A. Yes.. Q. You informed me that you wanted to plead guilty? A. Yes. Q. You do?

A. Yes. Q. You understand that by your plea of guilty this Court or the State’s Attorney cannot make any promises to you ? A. Yes. 699 Q. Do you understand that? A. Yes.

Q. This doesn’t mean that you are going to get probation. You understand that? A. Yes. Q. It is up to Her Honor to determine what disposition will be made of your case.

A. Yes. Q. Has anybody coerced you or made any promises to you to enter into this plea? A. No, sir.” (emphasis supplied) Later Tate’s lawyer asked him on the stand: “Q. Have you been satisfied with the advice I have given you, Mr. Tate? A. Yes.

Q. Have I called the witnesses and interviewed the persons you wanted me to interview? A. Yes.” Tate’s counsel thereafter said to him at the suggestion of the judge: “Do you understand that actually you don’t have to be sentenced today. If you think there is something wrong with your trial you can file a motion for a new trial and it can be heard by the Judges of the Supreme Bench. If you are sentenced now, then you have thirty days in which to appeal to the Court of Appeals.

Do you understand that?” and Tate replied “Yes.” It is clear that there is no substance to the appellant’s contention that his plea was not voluntarily and intelligently made. Gleaton v. State, 235 Md. 271 ; Berndt v. State, 235 Md. 565 .