Maryland case law › Tellington v. State

Tellington v. State

336 Md. 567 (1994) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals of Maryland granted certiorari to determine whether a circuit court judge's in-chambers statements during a pretrial conference were so coercive as to deprive the Petitioner of his right to a de novo jury trial on appeal from a District Court judgment. The Petitioner, convicted in the District Court, sought a de novo appeal in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. During a pretrial conference, the circuit court judge indicated that if the Petitioner asserted his right to a jury trial and was found guilty, he would be sentenced to incarceration rather than receive probation or a suspended sentence, and would also be assessed the cost of the jury. The Petitioner challenged these statements as coercive, arguing they penalized his exercise of the right to a jury trial. The State, through the Attorney General, conceded that if the petition w
Questions presented
  • Whether statements made by the circuit court judge in chambers during a pretrial conference were so coercive as to deprive the Petitioner of his right to a de novo jury trial on appeal from a judgment of the District Court of Maryland.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM. We granted certiorari to consider whether statements made by the circuit court judge in chambers during a pretrial conference were so coercive as to deprive the Petitioner of his right to a de novo jury trial on appeal from a judgment of the District Court of Maryland. Our review of the case discloses that the circuit court judge indicated that if petitioner asserted his right to a jury trial, and the verdict was guilty, he would be sentenced to a term of incarceration rather than afforded probation or a suspended sentence; and would also be assessed the cost of the jury. The Attorney General, on behalf of the State, in its answer to the petition, suggests that if this Court should conclude that the petition is meritorious, we should dispose of the matter by summary disposition.

We agree with that recommendation and, finding merit in the petition, we shall vacate the judgment of the Circuit Court for Baltimore County and remand the matter to that court for the purpose of permitting the Petitioner to exercise his right to a jury trial if that continues to be his choice. JUDGMENT REVERSED; CASE REMANDED TO THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR BALTIMORE COUNTY FOR A NEW TRIAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS OPINION COSTS TO BE PAID BY BALTIMORE COUNTY, MARYLAND.