Maryland case law › Thomas v. Clagett

Thomas v. Clagett

2 Md. 172 (1786) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involved an appeal concerning the admissibility of a deposition at trial. The plaintiff offered a deposition into evidence, but the defendant objected. The court (likely the General Court of Maryland) held that the deposition could not be read to the jury because it did not appear that proof of notice to the defendant had been lodged with the clerk of the county where the deposition was taken, nor did it appear that any notice of taking the deposition had been recorded by the clerk. The court's reasoning was based on the procedural requirements for perpetuating testimony, specifically referencing the Act of July 1779, ch. 8, entitled 'An act establishing a mode to perpetuate testimony.' The plaintiff appealed to the Court of Appeals, where the judgment was affirmed at May term, 1788. The case establishes that strict compliance with statutory notice and recording requirements is
Questions presented
  • Whether the deposition could be read in evidence to the jury when it did not appear that proof of notice to the defendant was lodged with the clerk of the county where the deposition was taken, nor that any notice of taking the deposition was recorded by the clerk.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court were of opinion, that the deposition could not be read in evidence to the Jury, because it did not appear, that proof of notice to the defendant was lodged with the clerk of the county, where the said deposition Vas taken, to be recorded, nor did it appear, that any notice- of taking the said deposition was recorded by the clerk of the county. Stone, for plaintiff. Chase and Jenings, for defendant. The plaintiff appealed to the Court of Appeals, where she judgment was affirmed, at May term, 1788.

See the act of July, 1779, c. 8. entitled “ an act establishing a mode to perpetuate testimony.”