Maryland case law › Thomas v. Pile

Thomas v. Pile

3 Md. 241 (1794) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a freedom petition in which the petitioner sought to prove descent from a free white woman. At trial, the petitioner offered the declarations of a certain Mrs. Smith to establish that fact. The defendant then sought to impeach Mrs. Smith's credibility by proving that she was a woman who, by general neighborhood reputation, associated and kept company with negroes. The petitioner objected to this impeachment evidence. The court, consisting of A. Chase, Ch. J. and J. T. Chase, J., was of opinion that the evidence was improper and refused to allow it to be offered to the jury. The defendant excepted to this ruling. The jury returned a verdict for the petitioner, and judgment was entered for freedom. The sole legal question presented on the bill of exceptions was whether the trial court erred in excluding evidence that a declarant, whose declarations were offered to prov
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in refusing to allow the defendant to impeach the credit of Mrs. Smith, whose declarations the petitioner offered to prove descent from a free white woman, by proving to the jury that Mrs. Smith was a woman who, by general reputation of the neighbourhood, associated and kept company with negroes.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The following bill of exceptions was taken at the trial, to wit: In the trial of this cause, the petitioner, by his counsel, offered in evidence the declarations of a certain Mrs. Smith, to prove the petitioner was descended from a free white woman; and the defendant, by his counsel, offered to impeach the credit of the said Mrs. Smith, by proving to the jury that the said Mrs. Smith was a woman, who, by general reputation of the neighbourhood, associated and kept company with negroes. To which evidence the petitioner, by his counsel, objected; and the court [A. Chase, Ch. J. and J. T. Chase, J.J being of opinion that the same was improper, refused to allow the same to be offered to the jury. To which opinion of the court, the defendant, by his counsel, excepted, &c.

Verdict for the petitioner, and judgment for freedom®