Maryland case law › Thomas v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Thomas v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

234 Md. 636 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryRobert R. Thomas pled guilty in the Criminal Court of Baltimore on April 26, 1961, to violating the narcotic laws a third time and was sentenced to ten years in the Maryland Penitentiary. He took no direct appeal. On January 17, 1962, he filed his first post conviction petition, contending that (1) his conviction was based on illegally obtained evidence, (2) he was illegally arrested, and (3) his counsel had not put forth his best efforts. The hearing judge held that the voluntary guilty plea precluded him from raising the illegality of the evidence, found the illegal arrest contention without merit, and apparently did not pass on the ineffective assistance contention. Thomas did not apply for leave to appeal. On September 18, 1963, Thomas filed a second post conviction petition, renewing contentions (1) and (2) and adding (3) that his guilty plea was induced by the illegal search and se
Questions presented
  • Whether the hearing judge correctly held that the first and second contentions (illegally obtained evidence and illegal arrest) could not be raised a second time in a second post conviction petition.
  • Whether the hearing judge correctly held that the fourth and fifth contentions (erroneous indictment as a third rather than second offender and erroneous presentation of prior criminal record to the Grand Jury) were not grounds for relief in a post conviction proceeding.
  • Whether the hearing judge correctly ruled that the third ground for relief (guilty plea induced by illegal search and seizure) was without merit, or whether relief should have been denied on the independent ground that it could reasonably have been raised in the first petition.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On April 26, 1961, Robert R. Thomas pled guilty in the Criminal Court of Baltimore of having violated the narcotic laws a third time and was sentenced to ten years in the Penitentiary. He took no direct appeal. On January 17, 1962, he filed his first petition for post conviction relief, in which he contended: (1) that his conviction was based on illegally obtained evidence; (2) that he was illegally arrested; and (3) that his counsel had not put forth his best efforts in his behalf, but he did not then contend that the search for and seizure of the narcotics had induced him to plead guilty.

The judge who heard the first petition held that the voluntary plea of guilty precluded the petitioner from raising a question as to the illegality of the evidence and found that the second contention was without merit. Apparently the hearing judge did not pass on the third contention, but the petitioner did not apply for leave to appeal. On September 18, 1963, the petitioner filed a second petition 638 for post conviction relief, in which, in addition to renewing contentions (1) and (2) that he had made in the first petition concerning the legality of his arrest and the search for and seizure of the narcotics, he contended (3) that his plea of guilty was induced by the illegal search and seizure; (4) that the indictment erroneously charged him with being a third instead of a second offender; and (5) that his prior criminal record was erroneously presented to the Grand Jury. The judge who heard the second petition correctly held that the first and second contentions could not be raised a second time and that the fourth and fifth contentions were not grounds for relief in a post conviction proceeding.

He also ruled that the third ground for relief, (guilty plea induced by illegal search and seizure) claimed by the applicant, was without merit. Without passing on the soundness of the reasons for that conclusion, we think relief should have been denied as to this point on the ground that it could reasonably have been raised in the first petition. Smallwood v. Warden, 231 Md. 652 ; Code (1963 Cum. Supp.), Art. 27, § 645H; Maryland Rule BK48.

Application denied.