Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an ejectment action for a tract of land called Trueman's Hunting Quarter in Saint Mary's County. At trial in September 1747, the plaintiff tendered into evidence an attested copy of a certificate of resurvey dated July 29, 1714, made pursuant to a warrant of resurvey, the original certificate being lodged in the land office. The defendant objected that the copy was not legal evidence. The court directed the jury that the certificate was legal evidence, and the defendant excepted. The Provincial Court gave judgment for the plaintiff. The sole legal question presented was whether an attested copy of a certificate of resurvey, certified to have been taken from the original certificate lodged in the land office, is admissible as legal evidence. The court held that it was legal evidence, overruling the defendant's objection. The opinion provides no further reasoning or citation of au
Questions presented
Whether an attested copy of a certificate of resurvey, certified to have been taken from the original certificate lodged in the land office, is legal evidence.
EJECTMENT for a tract of land called Trueman’s Hunting Quarter, lying in Saint Mary’s County. At the trial of this cause at Saint Mary’s Assises in September, 1747, the plaintiff, by Henry Darnall send Jeremiah Chase, his attornies, to prove the issue on his part, tendered in evidence to the Jury an attested copy, certified to have been taken from the original certificate dated the 29th July, 1714, made in virtue of a warrant of resurvey, to resurvey the tract of land in question, which certificate of resurvey was lodged in the land-office. The defendant, by Philip ,Key and William Cumming, his attornies, objected that the same was not legal evidence. But the Court directed the Jury that the said certificate was legal evidence.
To which opinion the defendant excepted. The Provincial Court gave judgment for the plaintiff. Lib/ E. J. No. 10. fol. 728.