Maryland case law › Treadway v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Treadway v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

243 Md. 680 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryWilliam M. Treadway sought leave to appeal from an order of the Circuit Court for Washington County (Rutledge, J.) denying post conviction relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act. He had pleaded guilty to armed robbery on March 19, 1965, represented by court-appointed counsel, and was sentenced to ten years, later reduced to seven. In his petition he raised four contentions: (1) illegal indictment because grand jurors were unconstitutionally required to profess belief in a Supreme Being; (2) incompetent counsel who failed to advise him of the nature of his guilty plea; (3) illegal arrest; and (4) being held incommunicado, denied counsel, and having confessed. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, addressed each. On the first, although not ruled on below, the Court summarily disposed of it: because Treadway's conviction became final before October 11, 1965, the dat
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant was illegally indicted because members of the grand jury were unconstitutionally required to profess a belief in the existence of a Supreme Being as a condition precedent to service on that panel.
  • Whether the applicant's court appointed attorney was incompetent and had failed to advise him of the nature of his guilty plea.
  • Whether the applicant was illegally arrested.
  • Whether the applicant was held incommunicado after his arrest, denied assistance of counsel during that period, and while being held by the police confessed to the crime of which he was charged.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. William M. Treadway (applicant) seeks leave to appeal from 681 an order of the Circuit Court for Washington County (Rutledge, J.) denying relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act. On March 19, 1965 the applicant, represented by court appointed counsel, entered a plea of guilty before Judge McLaughlin to the charge of armed robbery. He was originally sentenced to ten years in the Maryland Penitentiary, but his counsel was subsequently successful in having the sentence reduced to seven years.

The applicant raised four contentions in his petition for post conviction relief: 1) That he was illegally indicted because members of the grand jury were unconstitutionally required to profess a belief in the existence of a Supreme Being as a condition precedent to service on that panel; 2) That his court appointed attorney was incompetent and had failed to advise him of the nature of his guilty plea; 3) That he was illegally arrested; and 4) That he was held incommunicado after his arrest, he was denied assistance of counsel during that period, and while being held by the police he confessed to the crime of which he was charged. The applicant’s first contention, though raised in his petition for post conviction relief, was not ruled on by the trial court. It can be summarily disposed of, however, here in this Court. The applicant’s conviction became final before October 11, 1965, the date Schowgurow v. State, 240 Md. 121 , 213 A. 2d 475 (1965) was decided.

Relief, therefore, which would be available to some under Schowgurow is not available to the applicant in this case. Thomas v. Warden, 241 Md. 730 , 217 A. 2d 356 (1966). In regard to the applicant’s second contention (incompetency of counsel) the trial court found that his attorney consulted with him prior to trial and fully explained his rights. The applicant chose to plead guilty at his trial, and after a thorough examination at the post conviction hearing, the trial court was satisfied that the applicant understood the charges against him and had pled guilty voluntarily.

At the post conviction hearing the applicant himself expressed satisfaction with the conduct of counsel at his trial. The applicant’s third and fourth contentions of illegal arrest and illegal detention and interrogation were waived after he 682 had entered a voluntary plea of guilty. We have held that a guilty plea, freely and intelligently made, operates of itself as a “conviction of the highest order” and constitutes a waiver of all “nonjurisdictional defects.” Gans v. Warden, 233 Md. 626 , 196 A. 2d 632 (1964) and the numerous cases cited therein. A freely and intelligently entered plea of guilty has been held to waive the defects inherent in an illegally elicited confession (McCoy v. Warden, 234 Md. 616 , 198 A. 2d 245 (1964)), an illegal arrest (Simpson v. Director, 234 Md. 618 , 198 A. 2d 249 (1964)) and an unlawful search and seizure (Ogle v. Warden, 236 Md. 425 , 204 A. 2d 179 (1964) ; Plitt v. Director, 234 Md. 602 , 197 A. 2d 252 (1964)).

Application denied.