Maryland case law › Vernon v. Warden

Vernon v. Warden

11 Md. App. 340 (1971) · Maryland Court of Special Appeals
Maryland Court of Special AppealsDisposition: VacatedOrth✓ Good law
SummaryAnthony Vernon, Jr., was convicted by a jury in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County on 6 July 1970 of robbery with a deadly weapon and sentenced to 18 years. He noted a direct appeal on 4 August 1970, was authorized to proceed as an indigent, and counsel was appointed; that appeal (Vernon v. State, No. 495, September Term, 1970) was pending and not yet argued. On 3 August 1970, Vernon filed a petition in proper person collaterally attacking the judgment under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act. The State answered on 18 August. By order of 16 September 1970, the Circuit Court for Baltimore County denied relief, incorporating a memorandum opinion stating that the allegations of constitutional violations were 'wholly without merit,' 'bold [sic] allegations ... unsupported by facts,' citing Matthews v. Warden, 223 Md. 649; Thornton v. Warden, 241 Md. 715; Green v. Warden, 3 Md. App
Questions presented
  • Whether the lower court erred in denying the petition for post conviction relief without a hearing and without appointing counsel for the indigent applicant, where the petition was his first under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act.
  • Whether the 1970 amendment to Code, Art. 27, § 645A(e), permitting postponement of action on a post conviction petition while a direct appeal is pending, obviates the necessity of a hearing and counsel when the lower court chooses to dispose of the petition before the direct appeal is final.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Orth, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. On 6 July 1970 Anthony Vernon, Jr., was found guilty by a jury in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County of robbery with a deadly weapon and sentenced to imprisonment for 18 years. He noted a direct appeal from the judgment on 4 August and on petition was authorized to prosecute the appeal as an indigent. Counsel was appointed for him.

The appeal is pending before this Court. Vernon v. State, No. 495, September Term, 1970. It has not as yet been argued. On 3 August, however, Vernon filed a petition in proper person collaterally attacking the judgment under post conviction procedures.

The State answered the petition on 18 August. By order of 16 September the Circuit Court for Baltimore County denied the relief prayed in the petition and included in the order was a memorandum opinion. It stated: “Now in this Petition, the Petitioner raises allegations that his constitutional rights have been violated. The Court has reviewed these allegations and finds them to be wholly without merit.

They are bold [sic] allegations of a denial of constitutional rights unsupported by facts. Matthews v. Warden, 223 Md. 649 ; Thornton v. Warden, 241 Md. 715 ; Green v. Warden, 3 Md. App. 266 . Such allegations afford no grounds for Post Conviction Relief, Smith v. Warden, 4 Md. App. 550. For the reasons so stated the Petition for Post Conviction Relief is denied.” Applicant applies for leave to appeal from the order denying relief.

We can reach no other conclusion from the record before us than that the order was issued without first having a hearing at which applicant was represented by counsel. As the petition was applicant’s first under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, this was pa 342 tently wrong. A hearing on the petition was mandatory and applicant was entitled to the assistance of counsel thereat regardless of the merit of the contentions. If he was indigent, counsel had to be appointed for him.

Maryland Rules BK42 and 44. We have consistently so held. Franklin v. Warden, 8 Md. App. 395 . We point out that by ch. 595, Acts 1970, effective 1 July 1970, amending Code, Art. 27, § 645A (e), an exception was added to the provision that a petition for relief under post conviction procedures may be filed at any time.

The exception is: “* * * where an appeal has been taken from the judgment of conviction to the Court of Appeals or Court of Special Appeals, it shall not be necessary to appoint counsel or conduct a hearing or take any action whatsoever on the petition, until the judgment of conviction becomes final in the court to which appeal was taken.” This simply gives the lower court the option, when a direct appeal is pending, to dispose of the petition under appropriate post conviction procedures, or to postpone all action thereon until the judgment of conviction becomes final as stated. If the lower court chooses to dispose of the petition before such determination of the direct appeal, it does not obviate the necessity of conducting a hearing at which the petitioner is entitled to the assistance of counsel if such hearing and representation would otherwise be required. Application granted; order denying relief vacated; case remanded for further proceedings.