Maryland case law › Warford v. Van Sickle

Warford v. Van Sickle

4 Md. 397 (1853) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Aff'd in partLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to Pegg v. Warford, decided at the same term, and involves a contest over a paper purporting to be the will of Miss Colvin, dated April 6, 1848. After two sets of issues had been granted—one at the instance of Pegg and others, and another at the instance of Landis and others—the appellees applied to the orphans court for a third set of issues relating to the April 6, 1848 paper. The orphans court awarded that third set. On appeal, the Court of Appeals, applying the principles from Pegg v. Warford, held that insofar as the newly granted issues were substantially the same as issues already granted, the orphans court's act in awarding them was void and of no effect. The Court examined the first three issues granted at the appellees' instance and found them substantially the same in their inquiry as some of those previously granted at the instance of Pegg and others.
Questions presented
  • Whether the orphans court erred in awarding a third set of issues relating to the paper purporting to be the will of Miss Colvin, dated April 6, 1848, when two sets of issues had already been granted.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. The facts in this case, with the exception of an additional one, are the same as those of Pegg, et al., vs. Warford, decided at this term, (ante 385,) and the principles recognized in the latter, must govern the decision of this. It appears from the record, that after the granting of two sets of issues — -one at the instance of Pegg and others, and the other at that of Landis and others — on the application of the appel 400 lees, the orphans court award a third set, relating to the paper purporting to be the will of Miss Colvin, of date 6th of April, 1848. So far as these are substantially the same, as any of those previously granted, the awarding of them was a void act and of no effect.

The reasons for this opinion, we have assigned in the case to which we have referred. We regard the first three issues granted at the instance of the appellees,, as substantially the same in their inquiry, as some of those granted at the instance of Pegg and others, and therefore reverse the order of the orphans court, in so far as they are concerned. The other issues were properly granted, and as to them the order of the orphans court is affirmed. Order affirmed in part and reversed in part.