Maryland case law › Warner v. Fowler

Warner v. Fowler

8 Md. 25 (1855) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on appeal from a judgment of the circuit court. The underlying dispute involved a party who sought to testify in his own case by making an affirmation under an act of Assembly (the act of 1825, ch. 117) that permitted such testimony only if the party's account did not exceed ten pounds current money in any whole year and was proved within twelve months after the first article charged became due. The circuit court gave an instruction that was challenged on appeal. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, first waived any question as to the alleged generality of the prayers under the act of 1825, ch. 117, and proceeded to hold that the instruction actually given by the circuit court was substantially correct. The Court reasoned that the act of Assembly under which the affirmation was made is in derogation of the common law and
Questions presented
  • Whether the instruction actually given by the judge of the circuit court was substantially correct.
  • Whether the account in this case showed affirmatively on its face a compliance with the requisitions of the act of Assembly under which the affirmation was made.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. Waiving all question as to the alleged generality, under the act of 1825, ch. 117, of the several prayers to be found in the record, we are of opinion, that the instruction actually given by the judge of the circuit court was substantially correct, The act of Assembly under which the affirmation was made is one, in this particular, in derogation of the course of the common law, and like all such legislation, is to be construed strictly. See Dyson vs. West's Exc'r, 1 Har. & John., 567. According to the principles of the common law, a party is denied the right of being a witness in his own case; and under our act of Assembly, he is only allowed the privilege if his account does “ not exceed ten pounds, current money, in the course of any whole year," and if it u be proved within twelve months after the first article therein charged shall become due, and not otherwise." The account in this case ought, in our judgment, to show affirmatively on its face a compliance with the requisitions of the act of Assembly.

This not being so, there was no right in tire party to make the affirmation, and as a consequence, it was extra-judicicil. In addition to this it should be recollected, that, the 15th section of the act of 1729, 31 ch. 20, is repealed by the 8th section of the act of 1785, ch. 46. Judgment affirmed.