Maryland case law › Wedge v. State

Wedge v. State

12 Md. 232 (1858) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe defendant was convicted of larceny in Prince George's County and brought a writ of error challenging the indictment on several grounds, including want of a venue. The Court of Appeals, per Tuck, J., affirmed the judgment, holding that all the defects suggested were cured by the Act of 1852, ch. 63. The Court reasoned that the statute makes the margin part of the indictment, thereby curing the supposed defect as to want of a venue, and that its design was to relieve prosecutions from technical refinements of the common law and should be construed rationally. The Court found that the accused, with the indictment before him, could not have been ignorant that he was charged with larceny in Prince Georges county and that his defense must be shaped accordingly. The other objections, if defects at all, were mere imperfections in matters of form which did not tend to the prejudice of the def
Questions presented
  • Whether the ruling of the court below on the demurrer was correct.
  • Whether the defects in the indictment, including want of a venue, are cured by the Act of 1852, ch. 63.
  • Whether the motion in arrest of judgment can be sustained on matters that could have been urged on demurrer.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. We are of opinion that the ruling of the court below on the demurrer was correct, and affirm the judgment. All the defects in the indictment, suggested in behalf of the plaintiff in error, are within the act of 1852, ch. 63, and for none of them can the judgment be reversed. The act, in effect, makes the margin part of the indictment, and thus cures the supposed defect as to want of a venue.

Its design was to relieve prosecutions against offenders from some of the technical refinements existing at common law, and should be construed rationally. Keller vs. State, 11 Md. Rep., 525 . We cannot suppose that the accused, with that indictment, before 236 him, could be ignorant that he was charged with the commission of a larceny in Prince Georges county, and that his defence must be shaped accordingly. (Decided June 26th, 1858.) The other objections to the indictment, if defects at all, are mere imperfections in matters of form, which, in the language of the act, “did not tend to the prejudice of the defendant.” As the reasons assigned in support of the motion in arrest of judgment, are based on matters which, if available at all, might be urged on demurrer, the act of Assembly denies to the plaintiff in error any benefit of that motion.

The subject of the motion, however, was necessarily considered in disposing of the demurrer. Judgment affirmed.