Maryland case law › Weir v. State

Weir v. State

39 Md. 434 (1874) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedMiller, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis was a criminal appeal taken under the Act of 1872, ch. 316, which authorized a defendant in a criminal prosecution to appeal to the Court of Appeals for review of rulings on the admissibility of evidence and other matters, provided that counsel for the accused first made an oath that the appeal was not taken for delay. The Attorney General moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that it did not appear that the required oath had ever been made by counsel for the accused. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Miller, sustained the motion and dismissed the appeal. The Court held that the making of the oath by counsel for the accused is a condition precedent both to the right of appeal in such cases and to the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeals to hear and determine the questions presented by the exceptions. The Court further held that the fact that the oath was made must app
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal must be dismissed because it does not appear that the oath required by the Act of 1872, ch. 316, that the appeal was not taken for delay, was ever made by the counsel for the accused.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Miller, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This appeal was taken under the Act of 1872, ch. 316, by the traverser in a criminal prosecution, for the purpose 435 of enabling this Court to review certain rulings of the Court below, upon the admissibility of evidence and other matters, to which exceptions were taken and embodied in the record. The Attorney General has moved to dismiss the appeal upon the ground that it does not appear that the oath required by that Act, that the appeal was not taken for delay, was ever made by the counsel for the accused. This motion must be sustained.

By the Act in question, the making of this oath by the counsel for the accused, is made a condition precedent to the right of appeal in such cases, and to the jurisdiction of this Court to hear and determine the questions presented by the exceptions, and the fact that such oath was made must appear in the transcript of the record transmitted to this Court. To such cases, that part of the seventh rule regulating appeals, adopted by the Judges of this Court under the provisions of the Constitution, which requires the clerks of the several Courts in making up the transcripts of records to omit “affidavits filed on taking appeals,” has no application. (Decided 6th February, 1874.) Appeal dismissed.