Maryland case law › White v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

White v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

211 Md. 623 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedBrune, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryNathaniel White was convicted of robbery on June 14, 1956, in the Criminal Court of Baltimore before Judge Carter. He filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, which Judge Michael Paul Smith denied. White raised five complaints: (1) illegal arrest; (2) confession obtained under duress; (3) impossibility of committing the crime because he was incarcerated at the time; (4) denial of the right to be confronted by witnesses; and (5) ineffective assistance of counsel for failing to call witnesses. The Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Chief Judge Brune, addressed each claim and held that none could be raised on habeas corpus. Specifically, the Court held: (1) an alleged illegal arrest may not be reviewed after trial on habeas corpus; (2) a claim that a confession was given under duress goes to its voluntary character and may be raised on appeal b
Questions presented
  • Whether an alleged illegal arrest may be reviewed after trial on habeas corpus.
  • Whether a confession obtained under duress may be reviewed on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the alleged impossibility of committing the crime because of incarceration at the time may be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the alleged denial of the right to be confronted by witnesses may be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the alleged failure of counsel to act and to call witnesses may be raised on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Brune, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Nathaniel White was tried and convicted on June 14, 1956, before Judge Carter in the Criminal Court of Baltimore on the charge of robbery. His petition for a writ of habeas corpus was submitted to Judge Michael Paul Smith in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, and was denied by him. The applicant complains: (1) of an alleged illegal arrest; (2) that his confession was obtained under duress; (3) that his commission of one of the alleged crimes was impossible because of his alleged incarceration at that time; (4) that he was denied the right to be confronted by witnesses; (5) that his lawyer did nothing for him, failing to call witnesses on his behalf. 1.

Illegal Arrest. An alleged illegal arrest may not be reviewed after trial on habeas corpus. Cumberland v. Warden, 205 Md. 646 , 109 A. 2d 66 ; Smith v. Warden, 207 Md. 628 , 114 A. 2d 892 . 2. Confession under Duress.

The question of a confession being given under duress is one that goes to its voluntary character and such question could be raised on appeal, but may not be reviewed on habeas corpus. Randall v. Warden, 208 Md. 667 , 119 A. 2d 712 . 3. Impossibility of Committing Crime. The allegation by 625 the petitioner that he was incarcerated at the time of the commission of the crimes and that it was therefore impossible to have committed such crimes on December 12 and 24, 1952, and January 12, 1953, was rejected by Judge Smith in denying the petition for a writ of habeas corpus.

In his opinion-letter, he stated, “* * * our records show that you were released from the Baltimore County Jail on December 9, 1952.” An examination of public records is authorized in habeas corpus petitions. Code (1951), Article 42, Section 5. The alleged impossibility to commit the crime cannot be raised on habeas corpus. Burger v. Wright, 189 Md. 699 (designated as not to be officially reported), 55 A. 2d 332 (where the full opinion is reported). 4.

Right to Be Confronted by Witnesses. The alleged denial of the right to confrontation by witnesses goes only to the regularity of the proceedings, not to the jurisdiction of the court, and cannot be raised on habeas corpus. Hickman v. Warden, 203 Md. 668 , 99 A. 2d 730 ; Bonsuk v. Warden, 203 Md. 671 , 100 A. 2d 645 . 5. Alleged Failure of Counsel to Act and Failure to Call Witnesses.

The petitioner alleges in rather general terms that his lawyer failed to do anything for him, and specifically asserts that his counsel and the trial court failed to call as witnesses in his defense three persons who were present in court at his trial. There is nothing to show that he asked either his counsel or the court to call them, nor is there any showing as to what facts they could have testified to, if they had been called. We find no charge of collusion and no allegations of fact from which collusion might be inferred. The matters now complained of go to the regularity of the proceedings, not to the jurisdiction of the court.

We do not find that they would call for the issuance of the writ. See Legrand v. Warden, 205 Md. 662 , 109 A. 2d 908 ; Randall v. Warden, 208 Md. 667 , 119 A. 2d 712 . Application denied, with costs.